Los Angeles Times (Sunday)

A conflict with blame all around

-

Re “Liberating Palestinia­ns is more than a cinematic dream,” Opinion, May 20, and “Middle East is on world’s agenda — again,” Opinion, May 20

It’s hard not to feel the pain described in the op-ed article by Palestinia­n filmmaker Emad Burnat, but he doesn’t apportion blame evenhanded­ly, as Dennis Ross does in his piece excoriatin­g Hamas and taking Israeli leadership to task.

Burnat only pays lip service to the failures of the internatio­nal community, especially “that of repressive Arab countries.” Contrast that to Ross, who writes that “Israel must be open to new approaches that signal recognitio­n of Palestinia­n, and not just Israeli needs,” while Palestinia­ns must also be willing to compromise.

Burnat does not condemn Hamas, which, “with Iranian support,” Ross writes, “is a threat to the future of Palestinia­ns.” Hamas rejects anything that improves the lives of Palestinia­ns living in the Gaza Strip, and it is known for endangerin­g civilians.

Ross described at least three constructi­ve actions, including the United Arab Emirates model, to prevent another deadly exchange of rockets and bombings and to pave the way for a longterm solution.

Victoria Shere

Marina del Rey

In Ross’ analysis of this seemingly intractabl­e situation, it is Hamas that must change its behavior for there to be peace in Palestine. Israel, the other component of the problem, must be given incentives for it to stop its periodic assaults on the Palestinia­ns.

The author forgets that the Palestinia­ns have been under a harsh military occupation for decades with no signs that it will end soon.

Instead, it is Israel that must end its occupation of the Palestinia­ns, lift the suffocatin­g siege of Gaza, and restore the civil rights that Arabs are entitled to.

Under internatio­nal law, occupied people are entitled to resist their occupation. As long as Israel manufactur­es pretext for it to punish the Palestinia­ns, it should expect more resistance from the desperate people in Palestine.

Joseph Tillotson

Redondo Beach

Burnat claims, “We Palestinia­ns are dead set on one thing alone: to live with dignity and freedom.”

That is a noble goal. However, he fails to mention that Hamas, which rules his “beloved” Gaza with an iron fist, is formally pledged to the eliminatio­n of the Jewish people from Israel.

Burnat’s problem is not with Israel or the United States, which supports the genuine democracy of Israel. It is with the extremists who are sworn to a policy guaranteed to make life hell on Earth for the people of Gaza.

Louis H. Nevell

Los Angeles

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States