Inquiry urged in Armenian genocide case
Lawmakers angered on victims’ behalf by misconduct in class-action deal.
Four influential California lawmakers called for an investigation into a $17.5million class-action settlement on behalf of Armenian genocide victims that a Times investigation found had been marred by fraud, diverted funds and a rejection rate of 92%.
U.S. Reps. Jackie Speier (D-Hillsborough) and Anna G. Eshoo (D-Atherton), the only Armenian Americans in Congress, along with Rep. Adam B. Schiff (D-Burbank) and state Sen. Anthony Portantino (D-La Cañada Flintridge), chair of the Senate Appropriations Committee, said they were disgusted by misconduct detailed in the Times report.
“I am deeply concerned and outraged by the issues raised,” Portantino said in a statement. “The Armenian genocide was a horrendous historical atrocity and descendants of those murdered should not be victimized or be denied their rightful settlements.”
Three Armenian American attorneys from Los Angeles, including prominent lawyers Mark Geragos and Brian Kabateck, secured the settlement with the French insurance company AXA a decade and a half ago. The funds were supposed to compensate the families of genocide victims with unpaid insurance policies and support Armenian charities selected by a French nonprofit.
The Times investigation found that the French nonprofit was never established; some of the money was sent to the pet charities of lawyers involved in the case, including their alma mater; and hundreds of thousands of dollars were directed to sham claimants. Less than 8% of claims submitted by Armenians around the world were approved, despite what in many cases
was overwhelming evidence that the applicants were rightful heirs.
“It’s clear by the dismal claims approval rate and finger-pointing that something is rotten in Denmark, or Glendale, or France as the case may be,” said Speier, co-chair of the Congressional Armenian Caucus, in a statement.
Schiff, who represents Glendale, home to a sizable Armenian community, and is chair of the powerful House Intelligence Committee, said he was concerned by the “ordeal” faced by descendants of the genocide.
“I think all of us who read these stories have been horrified that some of the survivors and their families may have been victimized again,” Schiff said in a statement. “I fully support an investigation to ensure all such survivors get the compensation they deserve.”
Eshoo agreed that “a full investigation” was “absolutely warranted,” adding: “It is shameful that fraudsters are profiting from the pain of the Armenian community.”
The settlement in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles was overseen by Judge Christina A. Snyder from shortly after its filing in 1999.
The Times described how various parties — the Armenian Ministry of Justice, claimants, a lead attorney in the case and a courtappointed French settlement board — voiced concerns to Snyder about the handling of claims and settlement funds over a period of years.
Among the irregularities was the award of some $575,000 to a Syrian man who had never applied for compensation and payments totaling $400,000 to an Iraqi man whose existence could not be verified. Some of those funds were converted to cashier’s checks in Southern California. Additionally, at least $750,000 that was supposed to go to religious organizations never arrived, church officials told The Times.
Snyder allowed some investigative efforts to uncover misconduct but repeatedly denied a complete audit of the settlement.
“The court’s refusal to grant an independent audit is equally puzzling,” Speier said in the statement.
Snyder previously told The Times that the judicial code of conduct barred her from speaking about the settlement.
She formally closed the case in 2016.
In statements from representatives, Geragos and Kabateck, both descendants of genocide survivors, denied any wrongdoing. They have blamed others, including other lawyers and a claims administrator, for the problems in the claims process and pointed out that millions of dollars did go to Armenian charitable causes.
Kabateck’s representative noted that money they sent to his and Geragos’ alma mater, Loyola Law School, was used to establish a genocide law center. Both noted that, despite complaints about the settlement to the State Bar of California, which polices the legal profession, and law enforcement agencies, there have been no criminal charges against the two lawyers or findings of misconduct on their part.
The Times’ investigation relied on newly unsealed records, emails among attorneys and confidential settlement records.
Authorities previously took action against three other lawyers in connection with the settlement.
A Beverly Hills attorney, Berj Boyajian, pleaded no contest in Superior Court to a felony and a misdemeanor charge in connection with making false claims to the State Bar; he ultimately served no jail time and later resigned his law license.
The State Bar moved against the law licenses of Vartkes Yeghiayan, a Glendale attorney who worked on the cases with Geragos and Kabateck, and his wife for allegedly misappropriating charity money. Yeghiayan died before trial; the case against her was thrown out.
Some Armenians in France and the U.S. have campaigned to hold accountable additional figures in the settlement. As recently
as last year, a member of the court-appointed French settlement board urged the L.A. County district attorney to launch an investigation, and similar requests have been made in recent years to the State Bar. There is no statute of limitations for investigations initiated by the State Bar into potential attorney misconduct.
Speier, the Bay Area congresswoman, raised the possibility of an investigation by the state auditor or state insurance commissioner.
Portantino said he wanted “continued investigation and transparency until the rightful recipients are justly compensated and any and all actions of potential wrongdoing are exposed and properly dealt with.”
The settlement and a preceding case against the insurer New York Life were lauded by Armenians in the mid-2000s. At the time, the community was still fighting for the U.S. government and others to recognize the 1915 genocide as a historical fact. President Biden finally recognized the genocide last year.
In 2018, the Armenian Bar Assn. — a professional organization for Armenian American lawyers — feted Snyder at its annual banquet, with Kabateck, one of the attorneys in the AXA case, proclaiming, “Every judge should take lessons from the Honorable Christina Snyder.”
In the wake of The Times’ investigation, the Armenian Bar Assn. expressed “profound sadness and concern” over the involvement of Armenian American lawyers in any improprieties.
“If true, these allegations not only violate the ethical aspirations of the Armenian Bar Assn.’s membership, but they represent a grave breach of our organization’s core values,” the group’s board said in a statement.