Tanaka loses round in battle to remain free
A federal judge has ruled that former Los Angeles County Undersheriff Paul Tanaka should not remain out of prison while he appeals his conviction on obstruction of justice charges.
Because Tanaka’s attorneys now will appeal the judge’s decision, plans that called for him to begin serving a five-year sentence next week will be postponed.
U.S. District Judge Percy Anderson, who presided over Tanaka’s trial in April, on Wednesday rejected claims that the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals was likely to overturn Tanaka’s conviction because of several mistakes during the original trial.
Those mistakes, his attorneys argued, included an improper instruction Anderson gave to the jury and his decision to allow prosecutors to question Tanaka about his involvement in a controversial clique of deputies.
Anderson ruled that the former undersheriff was not likely to prevail on any of the issues raised by his attorneys.
A jury found that Tanaka, 58, once the second in command in the Sheriff’s Department, played a leading role in a 2011 scheme to interfere with an FBI investigation into widespread inmate abuse by deputies in county jails.
H. Dean Steward, one of Tanaka’s attorneys, told Anderson he planned to file papers next week with the 9th Circuit, asking it to take up the question of whether Tanaka can remain free pending his appeal, which will probably last many months.
As soon as Steward does so, the Oct. 7 deadline Anderson set for Tanaka to turn himself in to prison officials will be set aside until the appeals court decides on whether to allow him to stay out of prison.