Cold takes harsh toll on homeless
New mayor decries response to mental illness after 4 people die in Portland, Ore.
PORTLAND, Ore. — In her final hours, as she tried to sleep in the wicked cold of a Portland parking garage and hypothermia took over her body, Karen Lee Batts became confused.
She began to remove her clothes. An attendant later found her on the garage floor.
“She died from hypothermia due to the severe cold weather,” said the officiant at her funeral Wednesday, reading from a newspaper obituary. “She suffered from schizophrenia, a mental illness.”
Several dozen people filed past her open casket at the Ross Hollywood Chapel to pay their respects, 11 days after her death.
Batts was one of four homeless people to die here this month in an extreme cold spell that may also have contributed to a stillbirth by a woman who was living on the streets.
In a city that prides itself on liberal values, the snowstorms and freezing temperatures that began battering Portland last month exposed holes in its ability to care for some of its most vulnerable residents.
Portland officials declared a housing state of emergency last summer after learning that almost 2,000 people — including seniors, people with disabilities and families with children — sleep in bushes, tents, cars and doorways here every night. Mental illness is common and appears to have played a dominant role in the deaths.
The first victim was David Guyot, a 68-year-old father of three, whose body was found at a bus stop Jan. 1 after he succumbed to hypothermia.
That was the same day the new mayor, Ted Wheeler, took office. In his first act, he opened the city’s Portland Building as an around-theclock shelter.
Homeless people crowded into the lobby to spend the night. But others chose to stay on the street, shelter workers said.
The next day, 51-year-old Mark Elliot Johnson, who had struggled with alcoholism and homelessness after his girlfriend died a few years back, was found dead under a blanket in a business doorway, the second victim of exposure.
“It’s horrible,” the Democratic mayor told a reporter as the frigid weather continued. “Nobody should freeze to death on the streets of Portland, Oregon.”
Then, on Jan. 7, Batts died. She was 52.
“She lived life on her own terms,” the funeral officiant told mourners, mostly family and friends from an earlier time in Batts’ life.
She had been a junior varsity cheerleader at Portland’s Grant High School and part of the 1982 Rose Festival Court, a citywide competition that her brother, Alan Batts, described as the highlight of her life. She graduated with honors, he said.
She attended college too, but mental illness eventually set in. She spent most of the last 20 years on the streets and hadn’t seen her brother or mother in more than a year.
“No one can hurt her now,” her brother told mourners. “She doesn’t have to struggle. She is at peace.”
Two days after Batts’ death, a woman at a homeless encampment delivered a stillborn baby and walked around with his body under her coat until police noticed her.
The next day, the cold claimed another victim: Zachary A. Young, a mentally ill man of 29, who was found at his camp in a wooded area in southwest Portland.
Talk-radio callers and online commenters wondered what their city had come to. The mayor told Willamette Week that the stillbirth was “a damnation of our response” to untreated mental illness on the streets.
At a news conference Jan. 10, he said the city had increased the number of beds for the homeless and that Multnomah County’s 36 warming centers had also helped. But more donations and volunteers were needed, he said.
At Batts’ funeral, one speaker suggested that the state create a law to encourage the reporting of dangerous situations in which mental health seems to be a factor.
“We could call it ‘Karen’s Law,’” he said, “or ‘Karen’s Alert,’ like Amber Alert.”
The mourners nodded in support.
Outside the chapel, the temperature was in the low 40s. Ice and thick slush still coated the streets, but it was finally warming up.