Los Angeles Times

Libby Schaaf ’s mayoral misdeed

-

Re “Oakland’s mayor goes too far,” editorial, March 4

We are or should be a nation of laws, not men; to be otherwise invites lawlessnes­s.

President Trump is performing his job as stated in the Constituti­on — he is carrying out the legally enacted laws on immigratio­n. President Obama enforced immigratio­n law in the same manner, maybe just not to the extent Trump is doing in California, and not under the shadow that Trump casts.

The first job of elected officials is to protect this country’s citizens and legal immigrants; doing as Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf did and alerting potential criminals, legal or illegal, that law enforcemen­t is heading their way is irresponsi­ble.

While we have an obligation as people to ensure that all within our borders receive necessary medical care, food and shelter, to protect possible criminals and encourage resistance to duly enacted laws is to encourage lawlessnes­s. Scott Miller Chatsworth

Last week, the Los Angeles Times published an article noting that 45% of California agricultur­al workers are undocument­ed. The Times Editorial Board should advocate for their amnesty rather than rebuking Schaaf for having the courage to look out for them and other undocument­ed residents.

Schaaf ’s message was empathetic and clear, unlike the vague “resist Trump” billboards used, somehow, as criticism of her actions.

Giving a heads-up to our hardworkin­g neighbors and loved ones that they may be detained and shackled, transporte­d to for-profit detention centers and held indefinite­ly without basic rights while awaiting exile is, somehow, “going too far”? Being privy and empowered by such knowledge, it would be immoral not to act.

Clearly the writers of this editorial are not at risk of deportatio­n, nor are their loved ones, or they may indeed determine that federal immigratio­n raids constitute the “most dire circumstan­ce.” Forest Borie Anchorage

The editorial states, “Local subversion of federal rules would be justified in only the most dire circumstan­ces.”

How dire is the situation on marijuana? Lee Gruenfeld Palm Springs

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States