Los Angeles Times

Much safer ways to boil water

-

Re “Carbon-free requires nuclear power,” Opinion, Sept. 24

Aside from hydroelect­ric power, the generation of electricit­y is the same for coal-fired and nuclear power plants. Both boil water to produce steam that drives electricit­yproducing turbines.

Since 2006, Mitsubishi Corp. has been working on a project to utilize the planet’s fourth-most common element, magnesium, combined with water to produce heat (fire) to power internal combustion and jet engines. Japan has recently manufactur­ed hydrogen-powered cars and filling stations.

There are plenty of flammable substances that can be used to make fire. Hemp is the best botanical for biofuel production due to its short growth cycle and flammabili­ty. California has millions of dead trees due to drought and beetle infestatio­n that can be harvested to burn in existing boilers. Exxon Mobil is developing algae as a source of biofuel.

Chernobyl and Fukushima should be reason enough to consider nuclear power as a last option for the production of electricit­y. Craig Simmons

Northridge

Ted Nordhaus and Jameson McBride make excellent points about the feasibilit­y of nuclear power, but there is one other point I would like to add: Socalled renewable power sources also have serious and unavoidabl­e environmen­tal downsides.

The negative consequenc­es of hydro power are widely recognized, which is why many dams are actually being removed from rivers. Wind power involves placing large rotating blades in wind streams; as a result hundreds of thousands of birds are killed every year in North America.

Solar panels last 20 to 30 years and steadily lose effectiven­ess during that period. They are loaded up with very toxic materials and thus become unrecyclab­le. Large solar power plants set up in the deserts destroy the natural habitat.

Nuclear power, which has been safely used in France for decades, actually has fewer detrimenta­l environmen­tal consequenc­es if properly managed. Erica Hahn

Monrovia

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States