France adopts tax on internet giants
Lawmakers approve a 3% levy despite a tariff threat from U.S.
PARIS — France adopted a pioneering tax on internet giants such as Google, Amazon and Facebook on Thursday, despite U.S. threats of new tariffs on French imports.
The final vote in favor of the tax in the French Senate came hours after the Trump administration announced an investigation into the tax under the provision used last year to investigate China’s technology policies. That China inquiry led to tariffs on $250 billion worth of Chinese goods.
“Between allies, we can, and we should, solve our differences without using threats,” French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire said. “France is a sovereign country. It will make its own sovereign decisions on fiscal measures.”
The tax amounts to a 3% annual levy on the French revenues of digital companies with yearly global sales of more than about $840 million and French revenue exceeding about $28 million. The tax primarily targets those that use consumer data to sell online advertising.
“Each of us is seeing the emergence of economic giants with monopolistic attributes and who not only want to control a maximum amount of data and make money with this data, but also go further than that by, in the absence of rules, escaping taxes and putting into place instruments that could, tomorrow, become a sovereign currency,” Le Maire said.
The Finance Ministry has estimated that the tax would raise about $560 million a year at first, but it predicted fast growth.
The tech industry is warning that consumers could pay more. U.S. companies affected include Airbnb and Uber. Chinese and European companies are also affected.
The bill aims to stop multinationals from avoiding taxes by setting up headquarters in low-tax European Union countries. Currently, the companies pay nearly no tax in countries where they have large sales, such as France.
France failed to persuade EU partners to impose a Europe-wide tax on tech giants but is pushing for an international deal with the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, which has 36 member countries.
“The internet industry is a great American export, supporting millions of jobs and businesses of all sizes. Global tax rules should be updated for the digital age — and there is a process to do so underway at the OECD — but discriminatory taxes against U.S. firms are not the right approach,” said Jordan Haas of the Internet Assn., a trade group whose members include Facebook, Google and Uber.
Another U.S. trade group, the Computer and Communications Industry Assn., also said the French proposal discriminated against American companies.
The U.S. investigation received bipartisan support from the top members of the Senate Finance Committee. In a statement, Republican Charles E. Grassley of Iowa, the committee chairman, and Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) said, “The digital services tax that France and other European countries are pursuing is clearly protectionist and unfairly targets American companies in a way that will cost U.S. jobs and harm American workers.”
Also on Thursday, Britain moved ahead with similar plans as the government published draft legislation for a “digital services tax.” Starting in April, search engines, social media platforms and online marketplaces that “derive value from U.K. users” will be subject to a 2% tax.
Small companies and unprofitable start-ups will be spared in the British proposals. The levy will apply to companies with more than $625 million in revenue if more than about $31 million comes from British users.
The tax is temporary and would be replaced by a global deal, which Britain has also been seeking through the OECD and the Group of 20 major economies.