U.N. meeting hears warnings about Israel
Plans to annex parts of the West Bank could be disastrous for peace, the Security Council is told.
UNITED NATIONS — The head of the Arab League warned a high-level U.N. meeting Wednesday that Israel’s annexation of parts of the West Bank would inflame tensions and endanger peace in the Middle East, and could ignite “a religious war in and beyond our region.”
Ahmed Aboul Gheit, secretary-general of the 22member organization, said annexation will also have “broader ramifications on the international security around the world.”
“If implemented, Israeli annexation plans would not only be detrimental to the chances of peace today but will destroy any prospects for peace in the future,” he told the Security Council. “Palestinians will lose faith in a negotiated solution; I’m afraid Arabs too will lose interest in regional peace. A new dark reality will set in vis-a-vis this conflict and in the region at large.”
The council meeting came days before the July 1 date that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition deal allows an annexation plan to be presented.
Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan in the 1967 Middle East War and has built dozens of settlements that are now home to nearly 500,000 Israelis, but never formally claimed it as an Israeli territory due to stiff international opposition.
Israel’s U.N. Ambassador Danny Danon told the council that “should Israel decide to extend its sovereignty, it would be doing so with respect to areas over which it has always maintained a legitimate historical and legal claim.”
The Palestinians, with wide international backing, seek the West Bank as the heartland of their future independent state. Most of the international community considers Israel’s West Bank settlements illegal under international law.
U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres opened the meeting with a call on Israel to abandon its annexation plans, an appeal echoed by almost all other speakers, including half a dozen ministers and deputy ministers.
The U.N. chief said annexation “would constitute a most serious violation of international law, grievously harm the prospect of a twostate solution and undercut the possibilities of a renewal of negotiations.”
Guterres urged the United States, the European Union and Russia to swiftly take up their mediation role along with the United Nations as part of the socalled Quartet “and find a mutually agreeable framework for the parties to reengage, without preconditions, with us and other key states.”
He also urged Israeli and Palestinian leaders “to commit to meaningful dialogue, with the support of the international community.” And he encouraged regional and international supporters of a two-state solution to help bring the parties back to a “path towards a negotiated, peaceful settlement.”
EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell backed Quartet action in a letter to the Security Council obtained by the AP that also said “unilateral annexation would inevitably have legal consequences for the international community’s relations with Israel.” A joint statement by six current and incoming European members of the Security Council said “annexation would have consequences for our close relationship with Israel and would not be recognized by us.”
In response to the threat of annexation, the Palestinian leadership has declared itself absolved of all agreements and understandings with Israel and the United States and halted all contacts. Nickolay Mladenov, the U.N. special coordinator for the Mideast peace process, warned the council that “this decision has had, and will increasingly have, a dramatic impact on all aspects of Palestinian daily life.”
Palestinian Authority Foreign Minister Riyad Maliki said “we will stop acting as the Palestinian Authority” the moment Netanyahu declares “the annexation of one centimeter or 30% of the West Bank.”
That means that full responsibility for the well-being and services for 4.5 million Palestinians will be turned back to Israel as the occupying power according to the Geneva Conventions, he told the council and a news conference afterward.
The U.S. is Israel’s closest ally and President Trump’s administration has taken a much softer line toward Israeli settlements than its predecessors.
Trump’s Mideast plan, unveiled in January, envisions leaving some 30% of the West Bank territory under permanent Israeli control while giving the Palestinians expanded autonomy in the rest of the area. The Palestinians have rejected the plan, saying it is unfairly biased toward Israel.
With Trump’s reelection prospects uncertain in November, Israeli hard-liners have urged Netanyahu to move ahead with annexation quickly.
Maliki said deliberations have been taking place in the White House on the annexation issue for the last two days.
“Everybody knows that if there is anyone who could really stop Netanyahu from annexation ... it’s the Trump administration,” he said. “We hope that the Trump administration will give clear instructions to Netanyahu not to go ahead with annexation, and to open up the opportunity for potential resumption of negotiations between the Palestinians and the Israelis.”
Senior Palestinian officials gathered Wednesday in the Jordan Valley. The prime minister appealed to the international community and U.S. and Israeli officials with “the loudest voice” to stop the Israeli plan.
“Some say partial annexation. Some say full annexation. We will not accept any kind of annexation,” said Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh. “We will not concede one centimeter of its land.”
U.S. Ambassador Kelly Craft said many council members “have concerns with this issue of the potential extension of Israeli sovereignty in the West Bank.”
“At the same time, we ask that you also hold the Palestinian leadership accountable for acts they are responsible for,” she said.
Craft urged Palestinian leaders to look closely at Trump’s plan “and engage us,” stressing that “it is an opening offer.”