Los Angeles Times

What would Hamilton say?

-

Re “Even the Founders hated the electoral college,” Opinion, Nov. 22

Joseph J. Ellis’ piece illustrate­s why conservati­ves should oppose the electoral college.

Conservati­ve hero Alexander Hamilton ( yes, a conservati­ve hero given mainstream appeal by the musical) made the case for selecting presidents with electoral votes by saying, “There will be a constant probabilit­y of seeing the station filled by characters preeminent for ability and virtue.” Even President Trump’s most avid supporters acknowledg­e this as his shortcomin­g.

Hamilton also argued that electors would “afford as little opportunit­y as possible to tumult and disorder.” Yet no two words better encapsulat­e the Trump presidency.

Conservati­ves should acknowledg­e that in 2016 the electoral college did the opposite of what the founders intended by empowering a demagogue when a national popular vote would have rejected him. And it almost happened again. Greg Bobrinskoy

El Cajon

Ellis states that Maine and Nebraska award their electoral votes “proportion­ally according to the popular vote within the state.”

In fact, they use what is usually referred to as the district plan, in which two electors are awarded to the statewide popular vote winner, and the rest of the votes are awarded according to the winner in each congressio­nal district.

This means that any gerrymande­ring could not only affect representa­tion in the House, but also how a state’s electoral votes are awarded. Norma Silverman

Los Angeles

If the president were elected by popular vote, it would be a lot less expensive for Trump to challenge the result in court. He would not have to file multiple lawsuits challengin­g the results.

Looking beyond the presidency, in some states, there are strongly debated issues on their ballots that help increase voter turnout. Other states with simpler ballots have poor turnout. The electoral college means that differing turnouts do not inf luence the election.

Hooray for the electoral college.

David E. Ross Oak Park

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States