Racist text scandal hearing ends without testimony from officers
A court hearing to determine whether Northern California police officers who traded racist text messages violated a state law aimed at eliminating racism in the criminal justice system adjourned Friday without any officers taking the stand to answer questions about the scandal that has roiled the San Francisco Bay Area city.
Defense attorneys for four men charged with murder and attempted murder in a 2021 shooting had subpoenaed the Antioch police officers to testify about heavily redacted text messages made public in April by the Contra Costa County District Attorney's office.
The attorneys were expected to argue before Judge David Goldstein that their clients, two of them mentioned in the text messages, were unfairly targeted based on their race. The state's Racial Justice Act prohibits the state from pursuing or securing criminal convictions or sentences on the basis of race, ethnicity or national origin.
But the judge spent much of Friday's hearing ruling on motions and not on evidence, and none of the officers testified. The hearing will continue in late August, and the underlying criminal case is on hold.
In addition to nine police officers subpoenaed and who were available to take the stand Friday are five others who were subpoenaed but claimed they were injured on the job and not medically cleared to testify.
In all, 17 Antioch police officers have been named for sending texts that discuss falsifying evidence and beating up suspects, that make racist and homophobic remarks, or that use sexually explicit language. Most of the messages were sent in 2020 and 2021 and go far beyond the case up for discussion in court.
Antioch Police Chief Steven Ford was also subpoenaed to testify, but Goldstein ruled Friday he did not need to appear because his testimony was not relevant to whether officers showed racial bias or animus. Ford was not the police chief at the time the text messages were sent.
Carmela Caramagno, attorney for one of the four suspects, argued that Ford's testimony was critical so the court could get a broad feel for the internal workings of the department and devise an appropriate remedy.
Caramagno said she also wanted to ask Ford why he signed off on declarations stating that five officers had suffered an “industrial injury” and could not appear, when an investigator for the defense had seen some of them looking “quite healthy,” “having pool parties,” and “walking briskly.”
Mathew Martinez, a lawyer for one of the defendants, said the officers were subpoenaed so they could explain in court why they sent the texts. But “they're all unavailable, indefinitely,” he said.
The hearing comes two days after Ford, who is Black, made a surprise announcement that he would retire next month. He leaves after only a year serving as interim and permanent police chief. He did not respond to emails requesting an interview.
Lawyers representing eight of the nine other subpoenaed officers were also present in court Friday.
The four men represented by the defense attorneys were charged with murder and attempted murder in a March 2021 driveby shooting that prosecutors say was gang-related.
The Racial Justice Act allows defendants to petition the court for relief. If a violation is found, a judge could dismiss enhancements to charges or reduce charges. Goldstein in May threw out gang charges against the defendants after historical data showed county prosecutors disproportionately targeted Black people with enhancements leading to longer sentences.
Two of the defendants, Trent Allen and Terryon Pugh, were the subjects of some of the released text messages. Officers joked about kicking their heads and shooting them in the neck and buttocks. They also shared photos of Allen and Pugh injured in their hospital beds.
Shirelle Cobbs, Allen's mother, said she wants the officer who boasted about beating up her son in jail.
“He kicked him in the head. He talked about it. That's a crime. He put it in text messages,” she said outside the courthouse. “And they talked about it. He needs to be under the jailhouse right now.”