Commander of Chinese military in Hong Kong warns that protests are ‘intolerable’
BEIJING – Chen Daoxiang, commander of the People’s Liberation Army garrison in Hong Kong, said at a celebration of the Chinese army Wednesday night that recent protests were “intolerable” and that the military was ready to support Chinese sovereignty and maintain stability in Hong Kong.
“We resolutely support the action to maintain Hong Kong’s rule of law by the people who love the nation and the city, and we are determined to protect national sovereignty, security, stability and the prosperity of Hong Kong,” Chen said.
The PLA garrison also released a self-promotional video that has since been widely shared on Chinese social media.
Slogans of “Fight Terror” and “Maintain Stability” flash in the video as Chinese military officers slide down ropes from a helicopter, drive armed personnel carriers, and shoot missiles against a backdrop of dramatic music.
In one section that mirrors Hong Kong police clashes with pro-democracy protesters, an officer shouts in Cantonese, “All consequences at your own risk,” then charges forward with an armored phalanx of Chinese military troops, shooting tear gas at a group of pretend rioters.
Later, the music turns soft and inspirational as video rolls of civilians wiping sweat off officers’ faces and praising the PLA for being “strong,” “neat” and “handsome.”
Analysts say Chen’s comments and the video are part of a propaganda effort aimed at stoking domestic nationalism and putting psychological pressure on the protesters, but that military action remains unlikely.
“The videos and statements are for a domestic audience, to show that they’re very determined to protect sovereignty and crush rebellious elements,” said Ho-fung Hung, a sociologist at Johns Hopkins University.
But Beijing will likely only “heat up the rhetoric” without actually sending in troops, which would be too much of a liability for President Xi Jinping, he said.
“If the Hong Kong police accidentally or intentionally kill somebody or something bad happens, Beijing can always say the local authorities did it,” Hung said.
“If they use the PLA, it is going to be mobilized by the Central Military Committee and Xi Jinping himself, and if anything goes wrong, Xi Jinping cannot be exonerated from this.”
Beijing’s highest government office for Hong Kong affairs held a news conference Monday, where spokesman Yang Guang said the central government backs Hong Kong’s police and government, but did not directly answer questions about military intervention.
Yang, like Chen, only referred to a part of Hong Kong law stating that the PLA garrison will not interfere in local affairs unless requested by the Hong Kong government to maintain order.
Chinese officials have meanwhile accused the United States of orchestrating Hong Kong’s protests, which U.S. officials have denied.
Antony Dapiran, a Hong Kongbased lawyer and author of a book about dissent in the territory, agreed that the PLA video was part of a broader message of support for Hong Kong police, not an indication that intervention is imminent.
“The Hong Kong police are more than capable of maintaining order,” Dapiran said, adding that Hong Kong protesters have caused property damage, but not “rioted” in the sense of looting, fighting or harming passersby.
Beijing’s support will likely empower police to switch from merely dispersing protesters to making mass arrests at upcoming protests, Dapiran said, adding that young protesters are no longer afraid of tear gas, but might be deterred by riot charges and serious jail sentences.
Forty-four protesters arrested in clashes with police Sunday were charged with “rioting” this week, an offense punishable by up to 10 years in prison.
Beijing is walking a fine line between trying to scare protesters and going so far that China’s reputation is irrevocably damaged, said Willy Lam, professor in China Studies at the Chinese University of Hong Kong.
When the PLA first sent tanks and armed personnel carriers into Beijing in 1989, they were initially surrounded by residents and “stopped in their tracks,” Lam said, before later massacring student protesters.
Xi does not want that scene to repeat in Hong Kong because it would destroy China’s reputation, drive a mass exodus of middle-class Hong Kongers, and cause the stock market to crash, Lam said.
Beijing might achieve its psychological goals by deploying only a few hundred of the PLA Hong Kong garrison’s several thousand soldiers to guard government buildings, Lam said.
“The best result, from Beijing’s point of view, will be that people will be scared.”
Chinese military propaganda is so far unlikely to deter protesters from continued demonstrations, including three marches over the weekend and a planned citywide strike and rallies in seven districts of Hong Kong on Monday.