Get scooters back on Miami’s streets
Just about everyone seems to be on the same page, thank goodness: 1.Those two-wheel scooters that commuters — and all sorts of other riders — stand on and ride in downtown Miami are essential to keep people moving; 2. safety is paramount — for scooter riders and the pedestrians, bikers and skateboarders they’re zipping around; 3. rules and regulations to ensure such safety is in everyone’s best interest.
That means it shouldn’t be that hard to get Miami’s pilot scooter program rolling again (sorry), and then make it permanent. It’s an innovative program that keeps Miami better serving its residents and visitors. Other major cities have worked out the kinks. Miami can, too.
Recently, the Miami City Commission, with Commissioner Alex Díaz de la Portilla taking the lead, suspended the program, which currently includes seven companies that provide rental scooters downtown. For him, there need to be some stringent rules in place for the program to continue.
STREET HAZARDS
He told the Editorial Board that he’s all for what’s called “micromobility,” but he’s concerned about some riders’ recklessness on busy sidewalks — even veering into the streets where cars whiz by; the number of scooters left scattered on sidewalks; and the lack of training for people who want to just hop on any available scooter.
“God help us if some child, anyone, has an accident,” Díaz de la Portilla told the Editorial Board. “We also need to have micromobility in Miami. But let’s do our due diligence.”
He makes several good points. He’s prepared to make them again at a special meeting scheduled for Monday to hash out the issues as the city proceeds to make the scooter program permanent. He wants any contract with chosen operators to include helmets for scooter riders; slower speeds programmed into scooters; docking stations for unused scooters; and penalties imposed should minors use them.
The pilot program currently operates in Commissioner Ken Russell's District 2, covering Brickell, downtown and surrounding areas, and it generates 7,000 daily rides. Riders must be at least 18. Russell told the Editorial Board that no fatalities have been reported.
One of the scooter operators, Lyft, blindsided by the program’s suspension, says that it wants to address the same concerns — and operators already are doing so.
SEEKING SOLUTIONS
“In the life of the progam, we have worked with Miami Riders Alliance, a local nonprofit. We formed with the other operators the Mobile Miami Coalition — all seven of the scooter operators — to build a bridge of
partnership in tackling some of these questions,” Caroline Sampanaro, a Lyft vice president in charge of transit and micromobility, told the Editorial Board.
The pilot project was first halted in December. “The coalition came together and implemented improvements. keep scooters on the ground,” Sampanaro said.
For instance, “We implemented a program — and ID scan — so we would be able to make sure the person is of age,” she said.
“We’ve hired street safety attendants working to create lower speed zones and no parking zones.”
MORE PUSHBACK
Many residents are against scooters for the same reasons Díaz de la Portilla wanted to suspend the program: sidewalk clutters and reckless drivers. Can’t blame them.
“The city has had a love-hate relationship with scooters and micromobility in general," Russell told the Board.
However, Miami can either move forward, or regress. Some cities are fighting scooters just like they fought against Uber, a futile effort.
Miami's smartest bet is to negotiate a deal with the winning scooter operators that keeps the city from becoming a scooter wasteland, and instead helps ensure that we are indeed the burgeoning tech hub we claim to be.
How can a city that's worked hard to move away from its car-centric roots kill a program that creates alternatives for commuters?