But he drops ball on jobs
In an interview with Fox News’ Sean Hannity in Las Vegas, President Donald Trump went back to a favorite rhetorical target: the North American Free Trade Agreement, or NAFTA.
Trump talked about trade negotiations with Mexico and how he believes he can create a new deal that is fair for both countries.
“NAFTA was a disaster. We lost thousands of plants,” Trump said. “We lost millions of jobs. NAFTA was a disaster.”
On several occasions, we’ve looked at the tricky question of how to tally the employment impacts of the trade deal between the United States, Canada and Mexico enacted in 1994. In this case, Trump exaggerates the highest available estimate of lost jobs as a result of the deal.
“We lost millions of jobs”
Estimates of jobs lost from NAFTA ranges widely, but we have not seen any estimate as high as “millions.”
The biggest number comes from a report by the liberal Economic Policy Institute, which receives support from labor unions. A 2014 report from the group found that from 1993 to 2013, “the U.S. trade deficit with Mexico and Canada increased from $17 (billion) to $177.2 billion, displacing 851,700 U.S. jobs. All of the net jobs displaced were due to growing trade deficits with Mexico.”
But this isn’t the only estimate that’s been offered.
And as you’ll see, the numbers vary widely.
Business groups argue that trade deals actually boost employment, pointing to a 2010 report by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. The chamber found that the 14 trade deals in place in 2008 supported 5.4 million jobs, with the lion’s share of those jobs stemming from NAFTA.
Assessments not aligned with either business or labor have generally suggested that the trade deal had a modest overall impact on jobs, though with certain industries — such as cars and electronics — suffering more than others.
NAFTA “had particularly heavy, negative impacts on employment in the auto and parts industries, and a few others, such as electric appliances,” said Robert Scott, who authored the EPI report.
He added that the upper Midwest suffered disproportionately, though some of the production was moved to non-union locations in the South.
The Congressional Research Service, the nonpartisan policy arm of Congress, concluded that “the net overall effect of NAFTA on the U.S. economy appears to have been relatively modest.” A similar review published by the international Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development reached the same conclusion.
It’s also worth noting that assigning blame for job losses is not always clear. The U.S-China Business Council and the Financial Times have argued that the loss in manufacturing jobs were not due to trade with China so much as gains in technology and productivity, as well as the result of a more sophisticated economy.
And during the last year of his presidency, Bill Clinton signed legislation granting China permanent normal trade relations. From 2000 on, this had an enormous impact on trade between the two nations — and it overlaps with about half the period when analysts have tried to gauge the effect of NAFTA. This complicates any analysis of NAFTA’s specific impact.
For all its faults, Scott said, NAFTA’s impact pales compared to the job losses from expanded trade with China.
The Economic Policy Institute has estimated that the United States has lost 3.2 million jobs between 2001 and 2013 to trade with China, so it’s possible that Trump was conflating NAFTA and trade with China.
“Trump’s intense focus on renegotiating NAFTA, and his claim that under NAFTA ‘millions of jobs were lost,’ is not only wrong, but a vast overstatement, and a misleading misstatement of the principal sources of our trade problems,” Scott said.
The White House did not respond to an inquiry for this article.
Our ruling
Trump said that under the North American Free Trade Agreement, “we lost millions of jobs.”
We did not find any study that estimates that NAFTA alone cost “millions” of jobs. The largest estimate is about 800,000, and other studies show smaller negative, and sometimes positive, impacts.
We rate the statement False.
Trump said that under the North American Free Trade Agreement, “we lost millions of jobs.”
The verdict
That’s too high.