Tiffany tweet gets it wrong
U.S. Rep. Tom Tiffany, a Republican who won an open seat in Congress in a May 11 special election, is off to Washington — but still has his sights set on state government and how it is handling the coronavirus crisis.
Tiffany tweeted this on May 26: “First the health secretary says don’t go to hospitals or clinics, now the tourism secretary says don’t recreate. What next, the education governor saying no school this fall?”
The tweet linked to an online article from a Madison-based TV station. It came on the day Democrat Gov. Tony Evers’ stay-at-home order originally was going to expire. (The order was lifted May 13 under a state Supreme Court ruling.)
We can’t look into the future, of course, so we’ll have to set aside the bit about what school may look like this fall. But we can look back and see what Department of Health Services secretary Andrea Palm and the Department of Tourism secretary Sara Meaney said in regard to the COVID-19 outbreak.
Did Palm say “don’t go to hospitals or clinics?” And did Meaney say “don’t recreate”?
No.
And: Not exactly.
Department of Tourism
When we asked Tiffany for backup for the claim, his staff pointed to a May 24, 2020 story from WMTV, a Madisonbased NBC news affiliate, as it related to tourism and Meaney. This is the article that was linked in his tweet.
With a headline of “Wisconsin tourism officials encourage people to not
travel to seasonal homes,” the article noted Memorial Day weekend is the unofficial start of summer and went on to say:
Travel Wisconsin urged people to stay at their permanent residences when the ‘safer at home’ order was first announced in March and a month later the department’s stance hasn’t changed.
“Straight up answer, as the Wisconsin Department of Tourism we are not advising that people travel outside their home communities to recreate,” Meaney said.
The rationale: As people travel to cabins and summer homes, it could help spread the coronavirus and potentially overwhelm small healthcare systems.
In the article, Meaney acknowledged the state can’t stop people from traveling, and suggested those who do travel within the state take personal precautions, such as using face masks, and call ahead to see if any restrictions are in place where they are going.
When asked about the statement, Department of Tourism spokesman Craig Trost pointed us to an online toolkit focused on ways to stay safe while enjoying the outdoors.
The toolkit, created with help from the Department of Health Services, includes guides to safely enjoying parks and trails, going boating, fishing, cycling, camping and walking, using ATVs and UTVs, as well as a guide to going to the beach.
The toolkit includes this line: “We encourage all land managers, communities, and businesses that support outdoor recreation to use these tools to help create a consistent statewide message inviting Wisconsinites to get outside, stay safe, and be well.”
So, while Meaney discouraged state residents from traveling Up North, the department does not say to avoid any kind of recreation.
Department of Health
When it comes to hospitals and clinics, a Tiffany staffer said the congressman was “referring to the cancellation of elective surgeries, DHS encouraging patients to use virtual doctor visits instead of in-person, and DHS recommending that dentists postpone all elective treatments.”
But those examples have problems as well.
The April 2, news release from the Department of Health Services, cited by
Tiffany, called on residents to use telehealth options during the COVD-19 public health emergency.
Department spokeswoman Jennifer Miller said the agency has never advised against going to see a doctor, but has supported using telehealth — that is, video visits and the like — in some cases to get care.
“We want people to stay connected to their medical providers now more than ever, and to call their doctor especially if they are experiencing symptoms of COVID-19,” she said in an email.
Indeed, health facilities — including dentist offices — were declared essential during Evers’ stay-at-home order. That said, some hospitals limited elective surgeries and some doctors cut back on in-person visits due to concerns over the transmission of the coronavirus. Likewise, any dentist offices delayed routine things, such as teeth cleanings.
Those decisions were made by the health care providers and institutions, though, not mandated by the state. And those institutions have started to take in-person appointments and schedule surgeries again.
Our ruling
Tiffany claimed top state officials called on residents not to travel and not to see doctors.
While the tourism secretary discouraged folks from traveling to cabins and tourist areas in parts of the state with fewer hospital beds, the department website is focused on safe travel — not no travel. And when it comes to seeing doctors, the health secretary advocated using virtual visits where possible, but did not suggest residents avoid treatment.
We rate the claim Mostly False.