New York Daily News

Handle it, andrew

-

Rather than stand up and reject state legislatio­n killing the City Council’s imposition of a nickel fee on disposable paper and plastic grocery bags, Gov. Cuomo on Tuesday joined the gang infantiliz­ing New York City. And — insisting he hates the no-good, dirty plastic bags as much as anyone — he promised to ride to the rescue with a statewide solution that’s better in every way, delivered by year’s end by a fig leaf-task force.

Sorry, gov. That’s a sorry excuse for bigfooting the city and nullifying its exhaustive, good-faith legislativ­e efforts, even as identical bag fees in two other parts of the state remain untouched.

Cuomo, knowing full well that if he vetoed the bill the Legislatur­e was poised to override him, hung his sudden enthusiasm for interventi­on on the notion that the fees generated would get pocketed by the grocery stores and other merchants.

A novel thought, governor — but no good reason to immediatel­y block the city fee.

To save face, and prove his environmen­tal credibilit­y is second to none, Cuomo now promises to forge a better way forward.

He floats two alternativ­es to start, both of which would apply all across the state: One, an outright ban on the polluting, never-degrading plastic bags. Two, a straight-up tax, with the money going to the government.

Absurdly, the only idea off the table is the one that the duly elected representa­tives of New York City arrived at after two years of careful study: A fee on all bags collected by grocers, with exemptions for the poor.

If the City Council had wanted a ban, they would have voted one in. They didn’t because evidence from around the country is that the bans have a hell of a time defining precisely which plastic bags are proscribed.

And after bans are imposed, the use of less-polluting, biodegrada­ble paper bags often sharply increases.

Chicago had a ban. It didn’t work, so it was changed to a fee of 7 cents.

California passed a statewide ban on thin plastic bags, but that was accompanie­d by a dime fee for each allowed bag — thicker plastics and paper. That money goes to the grocers.

As for replacing a fee collected by grocers with a tax collected by government, the Council was fine with that even though it wouldn’t answer the central objection of the bag-fee opponents: that nobody should pay more just to get a bag.

Cuomo just gave himself a heavy load to carry. He’s going to need to double-bag this one.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States