New York Daily News

Bailing on his responsibi­lity

-

The Queens judge who sprung a 17-year-old accused of violent rape on $17,000 bail not only offended New Yorkers’ basic sense of decency; he flatly failed to apply the law. As the criminal justice reform winds in this city blow in the direction of greater leniency — keeping ever more pretrial defendants out of jail on the presumptio­n that it’s a punishment for poverty — Judge Michael Katz’s treatment of Donovan Fenton is a flashing warning of what goes wrong when the pendulum swings too far.

Fenton stands accused of entering a discount store in Richmond Hill armed with a knife, leading his victim to the basement and raping her.

This capped a furious year in which he racked up eight arrests, including for a knifepoint robbery of another store and for punching a teenage girl.

Prosecutor­s rightly asked the judge to set bail at a half-million dollars; Katz — a Civil Court judge sitting on the bench in criminal court on a Sunday — came in with his figure, 3% of that.

In defending the move, court officials could only cling to the lame pro-forma statement that “Setting bail is not punitive. It’s to ensure the defendant’s return to court.” Which is a dishonest dodge. While bail cannot take the place of postconvic­tion punishment, state law says judges must take into account the person’s “character, reputation, habits and mental condition,” “the weight of the evidence against him,” his criminal record — and his penchant for failing to appear in court on previous occasions.

Which is what Fenton did when, after getting a desk appearance ticket for the punch, he skipped out, leading to a bench warrant.

Prosecutor­s may get another shot at keeping this dangerous young man off the streets: A grand jury is to be empaneled Friday. Depending on its recommenda­tion, bail could be reset.

This time, God willing, by a judge with a functionin­g sense of justice.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States