New York Daily News

Juror brings a secret weapon

- Rich Schapiro

A QUEENS WOMAN was picked to sit on a jury minutes after she was arrested for carrying a collapsibl­e baton into a courthouse, the Daily News has learned.

The bizarre incident unfolded on Tuesday when a metal detector revealed that Dinorah Preyor, 30, was in possession of the baton on her way into Queens Criminal Court.

Preyor was charged with misdemeano­r criminal possession of a weapon and issued a desk appearance ticket.

To the dismay of the court officers, Judge Richard Buchter, along with defense lawyers and prosecutor­s, agreed to allow Preyor to remain a prospectiv­e juror in a child sex assault case, officials said. Preyor was ultimately selected to the jury.

One court officer called the decision a “slap in the face.”

Dennis Quirk, president of the New York State Court Officers Associatio­n, had a similar reaction.

“It’s a disgrace,” Quirk said. “How can you take someone who was just arrested and think they’re going to be an impartial member of a jury?”

Lucian Chalfen, spokesman for the Office of Court Administra­tion, defended Buchter.

“The judge was made aware during the jury selection process of the prospectiv­e juror’s arrest, and exercising his discretion, he, along with counsel from both the prosecutio­n and defense, questioned the person,” Chalfen said.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States