‘Cocaine is cocaine’
Chuck: End powder-crack sentencing disparity
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer on Monday called on lawmakers to end a sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine that has had a disproportionate effect on Black Americans.
“We have a moment to balance the scales of justice,” the New York Democrat said at a news conference outside the Thurgood Marshall U.S Courthouse in lower Manhattan. “It’s common sense: Cocaine is cocaine, and the sentencing should be equal.”
In September, the House overwhelmingly passed legislation to end a sentencing formula that uses an 18-to-1 ratio in treating equal amounts of crack and powder cocaine. The bipartisan vote was 361 to 66.
Democrats and Republicans embraced the chance to correct what activists, researchers and law enforcement view as a historical wrong. Pricey powder cocaine has long been seen as the province of the wealthy, while crack is cheaper and generally associated with poorer Americans.
In the fiscal year 2020, 77% of crack cocaine trafficking offenders were Black and 6% were white, according to the U.S. Sentencing Commission. A 2015 report by NYU researchers found crack users were more likely to report a lifetime arrest or multiple recent arrests than powder cocaine users.
“This act simply rights a wrong in the federal criminal justice system,” Darcel Clark, the Bronx district attorney, said at the news conference. “It will end the outdated practice that disproportionately harms communities of color.”
But the bill, called the Eliminating a Quantifiably Unjust Application of the Law Act, has not yet landed on the floor of the Senate this spring, with both parties moving cautiously ahead of the pivotal midterm elections in November.
Schumer, who declined to describe a time line for passage, appeared to be embarking upon a pressure campaign meant to clear space for the legislation’s approval without a fierce fight
on the floor.
In the Senate, Sens. Rob Portman (R-Ohio) and Cory Booker (D-N.J.) are sponsoring the legislation to end the sentencing disparities.
“We’re working together — Sens. Booker, Portman and myself — figuring out the right time frame and the right way to go,” Schumer told reporters Monday. “We want to get this done as soon as we can.”
Booker’s office said Monday that the legislation has picked up 21 co-sponsors, including 11 Republicans, since it was introduced in the Senate in January. Booker said in a statement he was “pleased that Leader Schumer has called for a vote on the bill.”
“For decades, our nation’s drug laws have been overly punitive and fraught with racial disparities, but perhaps no law has been as fundamentally flawed as the crack and powder cocaine sentencing disparity,” Booker said in the statement. “I look forward to passing the EQUAL Act as soon as possible.”
Beginning in 1986, mandatory minimum sentences for crack cocaine and powder cocaine crimes were formulated using a staggering 100-to-1 ratio. The Fair Sentencing Act of 2010, signed into law by President Barack Obama, changed the ratio to 18 to 1.
“Some of our colleagues would say, ‘Well, I’ll lower it, but I won’t make it equal,’ ” said Schumer, who at one point held up sweetener packets as props during the news conference. “100 to 1 was horrible, but 18 to 1 was just as horrible, which it is now. 1 to 1 is fair.”