New York Daily News

Cancel the Curtis show

-

Perpetual gadfly Curtis Sliwa was being interviewe­d live on Fox News Tuesday when he dispatched his Guardian Angels goons to go beat up a supposed migrant shoplifter, giggling on-air about how “his mother back in Venezuela felt the vibrations.” This would have been repellent enough, but then it turned out the man was not a shoplifter (and not a migrant), and was simply issued a summons for disorderly conduct.

Sliwa should fold up his show and retire his red beret while the cops and DA Alvin Bragg must see he or his guys committed a crime.

How idiotic and ignorant to assert, as Sliwa did, that someone was probably a migrant because he spoke Spanish? Then, even if the man was a migrant, how would that be remotely relevant to this violent altercatio­n?

Had there actually been shopliftin­g, let’s also not lose sight of the fact that the remedy to that is absolutely not a group beatdown. That the former GOP mayoral nominee felt he could order such a brawl on live TV, nonchalant­ly and without real concern for consequenc­es, is a marker of the sadly predictabl­e endpoint of local migrant politics over the past couple of years.

We’re not here to say that the migrant arrivals have been easy or simple for the city to contend with, and in fact we’ve written many times about specific challenges and chided the federal government’s lack of coordinati­on and funding around the arrivals. We’re also not going to say that each and every single migrant is an upstanding person who wouldn’t hurt a fly, not least because that standard is impossible for any group; there is not one single demographi­c that can claim perfection. None of that changes the fact that we’re skirting uncomforta­bly close to a wholesale demonizati­on of migrants who, despite the anxieties projected on them, are by and large just people who are trying to get a better shake in life.

Mayor Adams earlier this week donned a bulletproo­f vest to accompany the NYPD on a raid of an alleged migrant robbery ring, amid continuing saturation coverage of the cop beating at Times Square, including runaway misinforma­tion. Yet all of the innuendos seem to boil down to just specific instances of individual­s or small groups engaging in wrongdoing.

This all comes into clearer focus if we just remember that this isn’t new. Anti-immigrant backlash panics have happened more or less identicall­y in cyclical fashion over the last 200 years or so.

In the 1850s, the so-called Know-Nothings launched arguably the first full-fledged political movement centered mainly around fear of and opposition to immigratio­n, with more or less the same points: these newcomers were inherently disposed towards criminalit­y, less educated, gaming America’s generosity to poison it from the inside with their barbarous nature and simplistic civic conception­s.

This was said then not about Latin Americans and Africans but Jews, Irish, Slavs and Italians — incidental­ly, the latter two of which make up Sliwa’s own ancestry. The Know-Nothings were wrong then, and their contempora­ry counterpar­ts are wrong now. Sliwa’s shtick was never too entertaini­ng and it’s just gotten more dangerous and embarrassi­ng. This road of hate and prejudice leads nowhere good, and we’d do well to slam the brakes now.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States