New York Post

No Vouching for Sen. Warren

-

Senate Democrats were loaded for bear when President Trump’s nominee for education secretary, Betsy DeVos, sat down for her confirmati­on hearing last week — yet one of them used to share DeVos’ central goal.

DeVos has spent her life advocating for children and for parental choice in education to ensure opportunit­y for all, regardless of race, class, gender or ZIP code.

Such dedication is irrelevant to defenders of our nation’s dysfunctio­nal public-school systems. Yet at least one Senate Democrat wasn’t always a defender of dysfunctio­n.

Yes: Sen. Elizabeth Warren, progressiv­e icon, once supported school vouchers.

In her 2003 book, “The Two-Income Trap” (coauthored with her daughter, Amelia Warren Tyagi), Warren endorsed a school-voucher system to free children from the tyranny of educrats assigning them to schools based on where their parents can afford to live.

Warren wrote: “With fully funded vouchers, parents of all income levels could send their children — and the accompanyi­ng financial support — to the schools of their choice.”

Moreover, she argued that framing the issue as a “public versus private competitio­n” misses the key issue: “The problem is not vouchers; the problem is parental choice.”

Warren pointed out that most public-school placement is based on ZIP code. The only way parents can exercise any choice is to buy a home in the school district they want — but poor families lack that option.

The solution, she asserted, is to break up the “ironclad relationsh­ip” between ZIP code and school with a well-designed voucher system.

Yet ahead of the confirmati­on hearings, Warren charged that DeVos’ support for vouchers and privately run schools was disqualify­ing.

One might say that Sen. Warren’s hypocrisy disqualifi­es her from sitting in judgment of DeVos.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States