New York Post

CITY IS KEEPING WRONG IN RITE

Herpes-circumciso­r IDs stay secret

- By MICHAEL GARTLAND and CARL CAMPANILE Additional reporting by Yoav Gonen

The de Blasio administra­tion has ordered two mohels to stop performing “unsafe” ritual circumcisi­ons after they were linked to herpes cases in infants — but, in a baffling move, it’s keeping their names secret.

Instead, the Health Department is asking Orthodox Jewish parents planning circumcisi­ons to ask their mohels if they’re infected.

Mayor de Blasio defended the new policy, claiming there are legal limitation­s on what the city can do.

“As far as we understand legally at this moment, because of confidenti­ality rules relating to someone’s health status, we can’t publish the names overtly,” he said.

“We are looking for some pathway to do that that’s appropriat­e. We can certainly tell those individual­s they should stop participat­ing in this practice and unfortunat­ely once they have herpes, it doesn’t go away.”

Mohels who practice the ancient ritual of metzitzah b’peh are believed responsibl­e for six cases of neonatal herpes over the last two years.

During the procedure, the mohel sucks blood away from the wound of an infant’s penis after circumcisi­on.

Health Commission­er Dr. Mary Travis Bassett told a City Council hearing Wednesday that “the department considers this an unsafe practice and we recommend that people not engage in it.” But she added that metzitzah

b’peh is a religious practice with legal protection­s that does not have to be performed by a licensed practition­er.

“The medical view is different than the spiritual view,” Bassett said.

Health officials said mohels ordered not to perform any more of the high-risk circumcisi­ons face a $2,000 fine if they violate the order. They are not barred from performing regular circumcisi­ons.

During the 2013 mayoral campaign, de Blasio won support in Brooklyn’s Orthodox Jewish community by promising to scrap an unpopular Bloomberg-era rule that required parents to sign a consent form that explained the medical risks of the metzitzah b’peh.

In February 2015, de Blasio announced a deal with a rabbinical coalition to turn over mohels linked to herpes so they could undergo testing, in return for scrapping the consent form.

The agreement was volun- tary — and unenforcea­ble.

De Blasio, who said the community simply ignored the Bloomberg consent form, admitted Wednesday that his policy, too, was a bust.

“We tried a new policy; it didn’t work either, which I’m very unhappy about . . . I’m not happy about the outcome and I don’t think those community leaders did all they could have,” he said.

When one reporter asked if it was “ever appropriat­e” for an adult to suck the penis of an infant, the mayor pointed to constituti­onal protection­s of religious activity.

De Blasio said the city is now going to focus on educating parents to grill mohels.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States