New York Post

CITY THAT NEVER SHUTS UP

Why is this aloud? Night work OK’d despite outrage

- By KIRSTAN CONLEY

NNo matter hhow many times residents complain about late- night noise, constructi­on companies are given waivers to work into the wee hours, a review by Comptrolle­r Thomas DiNapoli found.

There’s a building boom — and it sure sounds like it.

Complaints about constructi­on noise in the Big Apple more than doubled in recent years — while the city just kept handing out more permits to allow jackhammer­ing and excavation at all hours of the morning and night, according to a report issued Thursday.

Constructi­on-noise complaints to the 311 hot line skyrockete­d from 14,259 in 2010 to 37,806 in 2015, the audit by state Comptrolle­r Thomas DiNapoli found.

The vast majority of those complaints — 74 percent — were for early-morning or late-night work.

Meanwhile, the number of “after-hours variances” — permission to do constructi­on work outside the standard 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. hours, sometimes around-theclock — shot up by 89 percent between 2012 and 2015.

During the same period, noise complaints — mostly for after- hours building — went up by 112 percent, the comptrolle­r found.

Noise complaints are perpetuall­y the No. 1 complaint to 311.

Even when the Department of Buildings was aware that residents were at their wits’ end, officials continued to approve the afterhours work, the audit found.

For example, the agency renewed the variance allowing con- struction until midnight at 100 East End Ave. in Yorkville 24 times between August 2015 and July 2016, even though the site was right near a residence that had made 112 noise complaints for after-hours constructi­on.

The city’s Department of Environmen­tal Protection is tasked with sending inspectors to look into complaints, but in 84.4 per- cent of cases examined by the comptrolle­r’s office, the inspectors determined that there was “no excessive noise.”

But they often get to the scene too late — an average of five days after the racket was reported.

In 2015, the DOB approved 99 percent of all variance applicatio­ns — issuing 59,895 and rejecting only 431.

But the agency says it cleaned up its act last year, approving just 18,164 of the after-hours permits.

A DOB spokesman says its officials agree with many of DiNapoli’s recommenda­tions, which include improving communicat­ions with the DEP and taking complaints into account during the permitting process.

The DEP defended its work, saying it maps the data and follows procedures.

One city source argued that DEP workers’ hands are tied — they can’t cite a company for making noise when the cacophony has been permitted by the variance.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States