New York Post

Coffee cancer-label threat boils over

- By LISA FICKENSCHE­R

A bitter legal “brew-ha-ha” that could roil the coffee world has kicked off in Los Angeles.

Starbucks and a host of other coffee sellers are fighting a lawsuit that alleges roasted coffee beans contain low levels of a carcinogen — and therefore coffee products sold in California, from lattes to packaged beans, should carry Surgeon General-like warnings.

A bench trial on the 7-year-old suit kicked off on Tuesday.

A little-known public interest group, the Council for Education and Research on Toxics, or CERT, sued roughly 70 companies, claiming the state’s Propositio­n 65, which requires warning labels on anything that contains materials that cause cancer, should apply to coffee.

Roasted coffee beans contain low levels of acrylamide, a carcinogen, CERT claims in court papers.

The coffee industry argues that the trace amounts of acrylamide found in coffee are too insignific­ant to cause a health risk — and foods such as toast, cereals, roasted asparagus and baby food all contain the chemical.

In July, the results of a study published by the American College of Physicians showed that coffee drinkers had a lower risk of death from a number of deadly diseases.

CERT lawyer Raphael Metzger argued in court this week that the benefits of coffee are “just a bunch of hypotheses” and that California­ns have been exposed to “really high levels of a carcinogen” by drinking coffee, according to Law360, a legal news service.

Others say that this suit and similar ones are being pushed by increasing­ly aggressive lawyers.

Prop 65 has resulted in warning labels in a host of unlikely places, including parking garages.

CERT doesn’t have a Web site and shares the same address as the Metzger Law Group, of Long Beach, Calif., which filed the suit. The firm did not return a call for comment.

Slapping warning labels on coffee would result in a “feeding frenzy for the plaintiffs bar,” Joe De Rupo, a National Coffee Associatio­n spokesman, told The Post. lfickensch­er@nypost.com

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States