New York Post

REPORT WAS AN ERR-BNB

Data biz zings Stringer

- By CARL CAMPANILE ccampanile@nypost.com

A firm that analyzes Airbnb rentals slammed city Comptrolle­r Scott Stringer on Friday for issuing a “deeply flawed” study using its data to falsely accuse the popular home-sharing service for double-digit rent increases in parts of the Big Apple.

“The report, which incorrectl­y interprete­d AirDNA data to make assumption­s on the impact of Airbnb on New York City rental prices, comes to flawed conclusion­s at great costs to thousands of Airbnb hosts that rely on the platform to make ends meet,” the firm said in a scorching statement.

Stringer’s report, released on Thursday, claimed Airbnb was responsibl­e for rent increases averaging 9.2 percent citywide from 2009 to 2016 and twice as much as in some coveted neighborho­ods.

But AirDNA, which is not affiliated with Airbnb, said the comptrolle­r got it all wrong.

“The comptrolle­r mistakes every unique listing ever uploaded onto the site as the number listings that were active in that year. A large portion of Airbnb listings are not active. They sit idly on the site, made unavailabl­e for rent by hosts and/or unbooked by guests, and therefor have little or no effect on rent prices,” the data company said.

It noted the comptrolle­r’s count lists all Airbnb listing types — whether they are entire homes or just private rooms or share rooms.

“To conflate these listing types is totally misguided and misreprese­nts New Yorkers that rent out a spare bedroom to supplement their income or help pay their mortgage,” AirDNA said.

The rebuttal also said Stringer “mistakenly assumes” that an Airbnb rental listed on the site — even if it is only available for one night in a year — has the same impact as a “full-time, profession­al managed listing.”

“Almost half of all active listings are private rooms. There are over five times more single-listing hosts than multi-listing hsots, and 65 percent of properties are managed by hosts with just one listing,” the firm said.

Airbnb spokesman Chris Lehane demanded Stringer “retract” his study, calling it a “hit job” that he suggested was engineered by the hotel industry.

Stringer Friday night stood by his audit. “Based on the informatio­n made available by AirDNA, our conclusion would be the same whether apartments were listed part-time or full-time on Airbnb,” a spokespers­on for the comptrolle­r said.

“Our report explicitly stated that Airbnb was responsibl­e for 9.2% of the increase in housing costs — not 100%.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States