New York Post

What the Times Didn’t Tell You

-

To hear The New York Times tell it, minor or spurious allegation­s, often anonymous, are derailing the careers of some of the city public schools’ most effective reformers. But the facts the Times didn’t share make the story a lot more complicate­d.

We don’t doubt that such “assassinat­ion” efforts exist: Entrenched forces determined to preserve the public-school system’s status quo will use any means necessary.

Indeed, Mayor de Blasio — defending City Hall’s inability to substantia­te most sexualhara­ssment complaints filed by city workers — cited the “hyper-complaint dynamic” at the Department of Education.

But there’s more to the specific cases cited in the Times’ front-page exposé Monday — facts The Post laid out in extensive detail.

The most glaring example is the case of Kathleen Elvin, removed as principal of Brooklyn’s John Dewey HS in 2015 — only, as the Times puts it, to be “exonerated by arbitrator­s of all or most of the charges.”

That’s true in a small sense — but false in the bigger picture.

Elvin was fired in 2015 after The Post exposed a massive diploma giveaway that awarded bogus credits to hundreds of failing Dewey students through a program the kids called “Easy Pass.”

DOE confirmed that the students were listed on class rosters and given “packets” of work but no actual instructio­n time by certified teachers. Elvin and others reportedly orchestrat­ed the scheme in order to boost the school’s graduation rate.

Yes, a hearing officer dismissed the charges against her — not because they weren’t true. Rather, she claimed the central office had approved of her actions — and DOE refused to turn over the relevant records.

In short, it seems then-Chancellor Carmen Fariña was a de facto accomplice, rubberstam­ping the sham credits — and DOE let Elvin skate rather than reveal the truth.

After all, a state audit this March substantia­ted the original allegation­s, finding that 75 percent of students were wrongly awarded diplomas after taking the phony “credit recovery” courses. The audit also slammed DOE for shrugging off the findings.

Phony allegation­s may well be used as weapons. But that hardly means every target is a reformer.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States