Still a Farce, not a Probe
For a brief moment last summer, new Chancellor Richard Carranza seemed set to break the logjams and turn the city’s three-year farce of an investigation into Jewish religious schools into something serious.
Guess again: Carranza has just disclosed that none of the Orthodox yeshiva high schools — always the real crux of the alleged problem — will allow city investigators in.
For years, activists have charged that some Orthodox schools fail to provide the basic secular education that state law requires. Even those elementary schools that offer a bare minimum of instruction reportedly end it after age 13.
In 2015, the de Blasio administration announced an active investigation. But years passed with no sign that any such probe was actually under way.
Now NY1 reports that Carranza has notified State Education Commissioner Mary Ellen Elia that 21 of the 30 targeted schools have been inspected (surprise: all “passed”), and three others have scheduled visits.
As activists note, the fact that the visits are scheduled instead of unannounced strongly suggests any investigating is being driven by the schools, not the city.
More important, six high schools won’t even let officials in the door, so Carranza is asking Elia for help. Elia, in turn, says longpromised new guidelines for such inspections are coming . . . real soon now.
Again, more than three years have passed — during which the politically potent Orthodox community, while fighting the nonprobe tooth and nail, got the Legislature to water down the education requirements.
City Investigations Commissioner Mark Peters is looking into whether political interference explains the city’s foot-dragging.
This is not religious persecution; it’s about ensuring that kids learn the basic knowledge and skills to function outside their community. Plainly, Team de Blasio doesn’t see that as any kind of priority.