New York Post

Muzzled by mayor

Cop-law testimony nix

- By CRAIG McCARTHY, BERNADETTE HOGAN and BRUCE GOLDING Additional reporting by Julia Marsh

Mayor de Blasio barred officials with the NYPD and the Civilian Complaint Review Board from testifying on Thursday about the planned repeal of a law that shields police personnel files — so they wouldn’t clash in public, The Post has learned.

NYPD Deputy Commission­er Benjamin Tucker and CCRB Chairman Fred Davie were scheduled to appear back-to-back before the state Senate Codes Committee in lower Manhattan, according to an official agenda for the public hearing.

But both men canceled their appearance­s on Hizzoner’s orders, according to a source familiar with the matter.

“Instead of letting both sides testify and having an honest conversati­on, they ordered both sides not to testify,” the source said.

“There’s been a debate inside City Hall. There’s been a push inside the Mayor’s Office for the mayor to push the NYPD to push for reform, further than they were comfortabl­e with.”

The controvers­y stems from a proposal to repeal Section 50-a of the state Civil Rights Law, which blocks public access to all government records used to evaluate the performanc­e of cops, firefighte­rs and correction officers.

The law was enacted in 1977 in part to prevent defense lawyers from using the Freedom of Informatio­n Law to obtain unsubstant­iated complaints of police wrongdoing, then cross-examine cops about those incidents on the witness stand.

Opposition to the law heated up when reporters and others were unable to get the CCRB records of NYPD cop Daniel Pantaleo following his deadly 2014 arrest of Eric Garner, over which Pantaleo was fired in August.

Garner’s mother, Gwen Carr, testified on Thursday that the law has kept her from learning about “the misconduct or discipline histories of other officers involved in killing Eric and covering it up.”

In February, NYPD Commission­er James O’Neill said he favored putting cops’ disciplina­ry records online but withholdin­g informatio­n when “the facts are not fully known” or when it poses a “risk to officer safety.”

Davie has never taken a public position on Section 50-a.

City Hall declined to comment on the mayor’s action.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States