New York Post

More Criminal-Justice Reform?

-

Even as prosecutor­s and police across New York are struggling to avoid disaster as one major wave of “criminal-justice reform” kicks in Jan. 1, pressure is mounting for yet another round.

New York City’s top legal-aid groups are asking the Legislatur­e for everything from marijuana legalizati­on to more restraints on police, as well as a softening of anti-prostituti­on laws and new early-release rules for older felons.

Yes, the list includes some good (or at least defensible) ideas. But the current Legislatur­e seems all too likely to simply give “reformers” everything they ask — without any input from the law-enforcemen­t community.

That’s what lawmakers did this year, ignoring even solidly progressiv­e district attorneys as they upended the system. As a result, judges soon will be unable to require bail unless the charges involve a handful of violent crimes. Hundreds of inmates across the state will be sprung from jail this month in advance of the Jan. 1 changeover.

Pot legalizati­on will likely take a separate course, as legislator­s find it involves a host of tough complicati­ons. Indeed, New Jersey lawmakers have finally given up on writing laws to enact such a shift, instead opting for a ballot initiative to force the issue.

As for the others: Is it really asking too much for the Legislatur­e to 1) look carefully at each specific “reform,” and 2) fully engage with the law-enforcemen­t community, rather than just signing off on a wish list from folks focused exclusivel­y on one part of the equation?

And, please, drop the “mass incarcerat­ion” rhetoric. New York’s statewide prison population is down more than 35 percent over the past two decades, to roughly 45,000 in a state of more than 19 million people. Everyone would like to see it go still lower — but “mass” is just a lie.

Most important: New Yorkers should get to see the impact of the changes already baked into the cake before lawmakers drop yet more wholesale “reform.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States