MENORAH LIT BY ‘IRE’ IN W. BANK
Israeli President Isaac Herzog on Sunday visited one of the most contentious spots in the occupied West Bank to celebrate the Jewish holiday of Hanukkah, sparking scuffles between security forces and protesters.
Herzog said he was visiting the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron to celebrate the ancient city’s Jewish past and promote interfaith relations. But his visit to the city, known for its tiny ultranationalist Jewish settler community and difficult living conditions for Palestinians, drew widespread criticism from Palestinians and left-wing Israelis.
About 1,000 Jewish settlers live in small enclaves guarded by Israeli soldiers in the city, surrounded by some 200,000 Palestinians, who must cross through Israeli checkpoints to move from place to place.
There is frequent violence between the sides and the Cave of the Patriarchs, revered by Muslims and Jews, was the site of a massacre by a Jewish settler who killed 29 Muslim worshippers in 1994.
Herzog made no mention of the 1994 massacre but paid homage to the more than 60 Jews killed by Palestinians in Hebron during riots in 1929, noting that a relative survived the fighting.
“I have no doubt that she would have been very moved by the fact that one of her descendants is lighting Hanukkah candles in the Cave of the Patriarchs as the president of the state of Israel,” he said.
Recognition of the Jewish attachment to the city “must be beyond all controversy,” he added.
The cave is believed to be the burial site of the Jewish and Muslim patriarch Abraham. It also is revered as the burial site of other Jewish patriarchs and matriarchs and is considered the second-holiest site in Judaism.
In his speech, Herzog made a brief call for “peace between all religions” and “to denounce all forms of hatred and violence.”
But critics accused him of embracing the most radical elements of Israeli society. Herzog is a former leader of Israel’s Labor party, which supports a two-state solution with the Palestinians. And his current position is meant to be apolitical and to serve as a moral compass for the nation.
Hussein Al Sheikh, a top Palestinian official, called the visit a ”political, moral and religious provocation.”
Several dozen Israeli protesters gathered about a half-mile from the cave, screaming “shame” as Israeli police held some of them back. Journalists and protesters were not allowed near the holy site.
Breaking the Silence, a group of former Israeli combat soldiers who oppose Israel’s West Bank occupation, also slammed the visit, accusing Herzog of “giving an official seal of approval to this obscene reality and the people perpetuating it.”