Mandate Madness
Is New York’s COVID-mandate madness finally cooling down?
Tuesday, New York state and the MTA axed their requirements for unvaxxed employees to get tested weekly. More crucially, Mayor Adams on Thursday announced the end — at long last — of the insane, cruel and utterly anti-science mask mandate for the city’s youngest kids.
All with good reason: The data on “public health” efforts like this are unambiguous. Mandates on masks or anything else have no significant effect — good or bad — on COVID outcomes at the city or state scale. They only add onerous requirements to people’s everyday life and work, empower Karens and jack up costs (the MTA’s employee-testing program cost a cool $100 million). Some outcomes are even more harmful: The toddler mask mandate caused behavioral and learning problems left and right.
The axing of these idiotic rules may be a sign that New York’s electeds are starting to reckon more seriously with a reality already understood by any sane person. On the other hand, Gov. Hochul refuses to end the public-transit mask mandate, leaving subway, LIRR and Metro-North commuters to envy NJTransit riders.
We’ll grant that Hochul and (especially) Adams haven’t been as ridiculous as many in their party would like. They began unwinding restrictions at the end of last year, though Hochul seems to wait for months of clear data before admitting reality, and Adams pays far too much heed to city health czar and COVID-theater aficionado Ashwin Vasan.
Crucially, they avoided returns to restrictionism. Schools stayed open over the objections of the teachers unions; there was no resurgence of the absurd vaccine passport system that helped keep the city and state mired in COVID panic for far too long.
As Adams rightly put it, if every new wave makes New York “move into shutdown thoughts [and] panicking, we’re not going to function as a city.”
That’s all the more true since testing stats have been revealed to be worse than useless: Recent data suggests that the city’s testing regime missed 1.3 million cases in this year’s first quarter. And case counts haven’t said much about the actual threat for a long time now, even though too many keep treating rising counts as omens of doom.
What health officials need to be concerned with — and always should’ve been — are deaths and hospitalizations. Both have stayed low for weeks (for months in the city) and are now indisputably (even according to Vasan) trending down.
Why? Because the pandemic is over. Immunity (from vaccines and prior infection) is near-universal. The virus is mutating to become less deadly over time, as routinely happens with pandemic diseases.
So the state move on compulsory testing is long overdue. As is getting rid of the NYC private-sector vax mandate (which already has a huge hole in it for celebrities).
We still need to hear the mayor and governor shout from the rooftops that we’re never, ever going back to restrictionism. New York can’t fully heal until it’s clear COVID theater is over for good.