Toss the ‘cap’ – so more grads can, too
FREE the charters: The right choice for New York’s families is obvious. Gov. Hochul’s plan to allow about 100 more charter schools to eventually open in the city should be a no-brainer, for all the reasons The Post laid out in our “Free the Charter” series last week:
In all too many neighborhoods, especially lower-income minority ones, the only good public-school option is a charter. But many ’hoods still lack that option, because state law prevents new charters from opening by “capping” the number in the city.
■ When it comes to teaching their students, public charter schools overall do a far better job than does the regular public system. In 2018-19 (the last preCOVID school year), 62% of charter students citywide scored proficient on statewide math tests vs. 45% at Department of Education schools. In reading, the gap was smaller but still substantial, 57% vs. 47%.
■ And that’s despite the fact that charters enroll few kids from higher-income families, and far fewer white children, who are usually more “privileged.”
■ Charters mainly enroll children from black and Hispanic, lower-income families, though that could change as efforts (in the name of “equity”) to lower standards in the regular system drive ever more white and Asian-American parents to seek alternatives.
If the cap continues to deny them that possibility, they may well leave the public schools (and even the city) entirely: DOE enrollment is already falling drastically, with no end in sight.
■ When it comes to specialneeds students and English Language Learners, charters do an exceptional job of addressing learning disabilities and actually teaching English, so that these kids are far more likely to be genuinely “mainstreamed” than if they’re condemned to the regular public schools.
“I have to say, I really feel that [first] charter school saved my life and my daughter’s life,” says Marcia Ward-Mitchell, whose daughter Kimana, who has autism and ADHD, is now 14 and thriving at her third city charter school.
“She can read,” says Azalia Lopez Volpe, “She can read. Like, she can read!” of her daughter Violetta, diagnosed with dyslexia in first grade and only getting the help she needed after switching to Bridge Preparatory Charter School on Staten Island, the city’s first public school that caters specifically to students with literacy disorders.
Sure would be nice to have such schools in all five boroughs — but the state’s current “charter cap” for the city prevents it.
■ On top of everything else, charters are also safer than DOE schools, because they have the freedom to put kids in timeout, suspend them, separate them — that is, to ensure that one misbehaving student doesn’t bring down a whole class, and to reduce misbehavior because kids learn actions have consequences.
■ Charters excel despite getting less than half the per-pupil funding. All by itself, that disproves the lie that they “steal resources” from DOE schools.
Hochul’s plan simply does two things: 1) Permits about a dozen charter allowances “used up” by schools that closed to be re-used by new ones. 2) Removes the NYC-only cap on total charters allowed so that the hundred or so still available in the rest of the state can be issued in the five boroughs.
Of course, after two decades when the Empire State’s “experiment” with allowing charters has proved a huge success, any policy reason for capping them at all vanished long ago.
Yet the Legislature resists, thanks solely to the power of the teachers unions — the city United Federation of Teachers and New York State United Teachers — which hate charters because they’re mainly non-union.
The UFT and NYSUT are elephants in Albany, spending millions in members’ dues to buy support and with hefty get-outthe-vote operations that are key to many legislators’ re-elections. Somehow, lawmakers normally obsessed with race ignore the fact that the overwhelmingly white unions fight furiously to prevent new hope for mainly minority families that want better futures for their children.
We pray that the governor stands strong, not using the charter issue as a bargaining chip to be traded for some other part of her agenda. And that enough lawmakers listen to their consciences, not to this special interest, and stand with the children.
The right choice couldn’t possibly be more clear.