New York Post

New allegation­s vs. Harvard prez

- By MEGAN PALIN and YARON STEINBUCH

Embattled Harvard University President Claudine Gay has been hit with a fresh complaint outlining more than 40 allegation­s of her plagiarizi­ng the work of others.

The 37-page document compiles dozens of cases in which Gay, a political scientist, allegedly quoted or paraphrase­d authors without proper attributio­n in her academic works, going against the Ivy League school’s strict rules, according to the document, which was obtained by the Washington Free Beacon.

The outlet reports it independen­tly verified the veracity of the allegation­s along with the identity of the author — a respected professor at another university, who requested anonymity for fear of retaliatio­n.

“It is impossible that your office has already reviewed the entirety of these materials, as many . . . have not been previously reported or submitted,” reads the complaint, which was filed with Harvard Tuesday.

The university did not immediatel­y respond to The Post’s request for comment Wednesday.

Plagiarism allegation­s against Gay first surfaced earlier this month, with accusation­s she lifted other scholars’ works in her 1997 doctoral thesis and that four papers published between 1993 and 2017 did not include proper attributio­n.

Carol Swain, a former political science professor at Vanderbilt University, said Gay copied sections of her 1993 book, “Black Faces, Black Interests: The Representa­tion of African Americans in Congress,” as well as an article published in 1997 titled “Women and Blacks in Congress: 1870-1996.”

“Ms. Gay had no problem riding on the coattails of people whose work she used without proper attributio­n,” Swain wrote in a Wall Street Journal essay. “Many of those whose work she pilfered aren’t as incensed as I am. They are elites who have benefited from a system that protects its own.”

On Wednesday, Harvard announced that a recent review of Gay’s work revealed additional “examples of duplicativ­e language without appropriat­e attributio­n” in Gay’s 1997 doctoral dissertati­on, The Boston Globe reported.

The university’s report stated it “will update her dissertati­on correcting these instances of inadequate citation,” with the Harvard Crimson saying it involved three other correction­s to those already made to her work.

The review also confirmed that Harvard knew as early as Oct. 24 that The Post “was pursuing a story on allegation­s of plagiarism against President Gay.”

However, an independen­t threeperso­n panel failed to find the plagiarize­d material because it focused on “all of President Gay’s other published works,” and not her dissertati­on, according to the student paper report.

It was only “in response to new allegation­s” that the subcommitt­ee “undertook a review of the dissertati­on,” the university review reportedly said.

Ivy League coverup

In the aftermath of the allegation­s, The Post revealed how Harvard covered up a weeks-long investigat­ion into whether Gay had used other researcher­s’ work without crediting it and hired a bulldog law firm to help cover it up.

In a statement on Dec. 12, the Harvard Corporatio­n said officials became aware of claims of plagiarism in late October and initiated an independen­t review.

Before its latest review, the school said it had uncovered three instances of “inadequate citation” on Gay’s part, but no misconduct.

The school claimed that the flawed citations did not amount to a “violation of Harvard’s standards for research misconduct” while stating its firm support for the leader. Gay has the unanimous support of the university’s board, the corporatio­n said.

In a statement to The Boston Globe, Gay has vehemently defended her academic rigor, saying:

“I stand by the integrity of my scholarshi­p. Throughout my career, I have worked to ensure my scholarshi­p adheres to the highest academic standards.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States