Twitter says 200 accounts tied to Russia
Dems criticize level of cooperation from internet giant
WASHINGTON — Twitter said Thursday it had found around 200 accounts linked to Russian interference in the 2016 election, a further sign that Moscow secretly employed multiple social media platforms to influence American voters.
The company said in a statement that 22 accounts were closed after they were found to be linked to separate Facebook pages previously shown to have spread Russian-bought ads during the presidential campaign that focused mostly on social issues like race, guns and immigration.
An additional 179 Twitter account were “related or linked” to the Facebook pages, Twitter said, adding that it closed “the ones we found in violation of our rules.”
Twitter’s disclosures, a week after a similar statement by Facebook, came in response to growing criticism of the company from members of Congress for not providing details about how Moscow might have used their platforms, ostensibly to help Donald Trump and harm Hillary Clinton.
Company executives on Thursday briefed members and staff of the House and Senate intelligence committees on their findings in a closed-door meeting. But several Democratic lawmakers said the company’s presentation left many questions unanswered.
Sen. Mark Warner, D-Va., the top Democrat on the Senate intelligence committee, was even more critical, calling Twitter’s disclosures “deeply disappointing” and “frankly inadequate on almost every level.”
Twitter has remained mostly silent in public until now about Russia’s use of its site. Like Facebook, the company revealed few details about the content of the tweets linked to Russia.
Rep. Adam Schiff, DCalif., said much of the information Twitter provided on Russian-linked accounts was derived from Facebook’s analysis and did not address whether the tweets were targeted to particular voters in an effort to sway their choice for president.
“It is clear that Twitter has significant forensic work to do to understand the depth and breadth of Russian activity during the campaign,” he said in an interview.
“Additional analysis will require a far more robust investigation into how Russian actors used their platform as a part of their active measures campaign and whether any of the targeting on Twitter suggests the possibility of assistance or collusion with any U.S. persons,” Schiff said.
“Twitter’s probably more important than we know,” said Rep. Jackie Speier, DCalif., another member of the House committee. Compared to Facebook, “they’ve been, frankly, less cooperative so far.”
In a statement, Twitter said it “deeply respects the integrity of the election process, which is a cornerstone for all democracies.”
It said the company is “in dialogue” with congressional committees investigating Russian interference in the U.S. campaign.
Use of social media was part of a broad effort by the Kremlin to influence the presidential election, U.S. intelligence agencies said in a January report.
Since the election, tweets from Russia have continued to promote divisive subjects, according to the Alliance for Securing Democracy, an initiative of the German Marshall Fund, a Washington think tank.
Its monitoring of 600 Twitter accounts linked to Russia showed that 25 percent of the stories promoted by those accounts in the last week had a strong antiAmerican theme, while around 15 percent criticized Hillary Clinton.
Like Facebook, Twitter has given its information to special counsel Robert Mueller, who is leading a criminal investigation into whether any of Trump’s aides coordinated with Russian authorities during or after the campaign. Trump has denied any collusion.
Executives from Twitter, Facebook and Google are expected to testify in public before the Senate intelligence committee on Nov. 1.