Florida asks judge to kick himself off elections law case

TALLAHASSEE — Saying he “appears to have a closed mind,” the state has asked a federal judge to remove himself from a case about the constitutionality of a 2023 Florida elections law.

Attorneys for Secretary of State Cord Byrd last week filed a motion seeking the recusal of Chief U.S. District Judge Mark Walker, pointing to parts of a ruling he issued Feb. 8 in a separate court battle about a 2021 elections law.

In that ruling, Walker entered a judgment in favor of the state after the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned his earlier decision that the law improperly discriminated against Black voters.

But Walker also wrote that the state “has, with surgical precision, repeatedly changed Florida’s election code to target whichever modality of voting Florida’s Black voters were using at the time. That was not this court’s opinion — it is a fact established by the record in these cases (involving the 2021 law). Even so, following the state of Florida’s appeal, this persistent and pernicious practice of targeting the modalities of voting most used by Florida’s Black voters has apparently received the stamp of approval in this (11th) Circuit.”

Three consolidated lawsuits challenging the 2023 law allege that the state has placed improper restrictions on what are known as “third party” voter registration organizations. Plaintiffs contend that the organizations play an important role in signing up Black and Hispanic voters.

In the motion for recusal, the state’s attorneys cited Walker’s description of a “persistent and pernicious practice” related to Black voters.

“Plaintiffs in these consolidated proceedings must prove that the state of Florida intentionally targeted third-party voter registration organizations because Black voters prefer to use them,” the motion said. “But this court (Walker) has seemingly concluded that the state of Florida engages in discrimination against Black voters. On the discriminatory-intent issue, therefore, this court appears to have a closed mind.”

If Walker recuses himself, another judge would take over the case, which is scheduled for trial in April.

The groups and other plaintiffs filed the lawsuits after Gov. Ron

DeSantis and the Republican-controlled Legislature last year approved the elections law. The plaintiffs argue the law violates First Amendment rights.

In a July ruling, Walker issued a preliminary injunction against two changes in the law. They would prevent non-U.S. citizens from collecting or handling voter-registration applications and make it a felony for voter-registration group workers to keep personal information of voters.

The state has appealed that ruling to the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, where it remains pending.