Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Pa.’s natural gas taxes are not out of line

-

If there ever was a good example for why natural gas taxes should be increased for school funding, it’s Pennsylvan­ia House Speaker Mike Turzai. His June 5 Perspectiv­es piece, “Don’t Raise Taxes on Natural Gas Producers,” is a prime example of either A) not understand­ing math, B) not understand­ing how to do research, C) figures never lie but liars figure or D) all of the previous.

The only facts he states in his piece are the revenues generated in Ohio and West Virginia by their taxes versus the much higher amount generated in Pennsylvan­ia.

What he fails to mention is that Pennsylvan­ia produces at least four times (closer to five, but I’m rounding down) more natural gas than either of those two states. A five-minute internet search showed Pennsylvan­ia is the third-highest producer in the nation, Ohio is fifth and West Virginia is seventh. Doing some simple math shows that West Virginia’s tax income would be higher than Pennsylvan­ia’s while Ohio’s would be close to the same if those states produced as much natural gas as Pennsylvan­ia. I suspect Mr. Turzai knows this but simply chose to ignore it.

If Mr. Turzai understand­s how to extrapolat­e and compare numbers, then he knows that our natural gas taxes aren’t out of line or excessivel­y high.

Using the additional tax revenue to help fund education would benefit all Pennsylvan­ians. Learning math and understand­ing how facts can be manipulate­d aregood for everyone. JOSH BAYER Lawrencevi­lle championsh­ip? What I think most of the team refused to attend was a politicall­y motivated, divisive event recast as a patriotic tribute to President Donald Trump’s victory over the NFL and its players, given the league’s new national anthem policy (June 5, “Trump Calls Off Eagles’ Visit Over Anthem Dispute”). That seems more a “slap in the face” to the Eagles and the NFL players than it does a recognitio­n of the Super Bowl champions.

Traditiona­lly, this is just a nice White House visit and photo op. This event was supposed to be about the Super Bowl champs, wasn’t it? TRACY SOSKA

Pleasant Hills

There is a double standard in our country that needs to be addressed. Roseanne Barr sent out a tweet that was deplorable, and she was fired immediatel­y and rightly so. Most people are not arguing that outcome. She was not on the air; she was at home and apologized and removed the tweet.

Samantha Bee, while on air, makes statements just as deplorable or worse and does not apologize until sponsors start pulling their ads. TBS apologizes also after it starts losing revenue. Does Ms. Bee get fired? No, she does not, and the very next night she getsan award.

We welcome your opinion

Ms. Barr is still in the news while Ms. Bee is forgiven. Why the double standard? I am not saying Ms. Barr should be forgiven. I am saying that if the punishment for this offense is being fired, then Ms. Bee also should be fired. I wonder what the outcome and outrage would have been if Ms. Bee’s comments were made about President Obama’s daughter and not President Trump’s? PATRICK CUMMINGS

Imperial

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States