Trump embraces Putin, doubts U.S. intel findings
Presidents steer clear of any confrontations
HELSINKI — In what was seen by many as an extraordinary embrace of a longtime U.S. enemy, President Donald Trump on Monday openly questioned his own intelligence agencies’ firm finding that Russia meddled in the 2016 U.S. election to his benefit, seeming to accept Russian President Vladimir Putin’s insistence that Moscow’s hands were clean.
The reaction back home was immediate and visceral, among fellow Republicans as well as usual Trump critics. “Shameful,” “disgraceful,” “weak,” were a few of the comments. Makes the U.S. “look like a pushover,” said GOP Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee.
Mr. Trump’s meeting with Mr. Putin in Helsinki was his first time sharing the international stage with a man he has described as an important U.S. competitor — but whom he has also praised a strong, effective leader.
His remarks, siding with a foe on foreign soil over his own government, was a stark illustration of Mr. Trump’s willingness to upend decades of U.S. foreign policy and rattle Western allies in service of his political concerns. A wary and robust stance toward Russia has been a bedrock of his party’s world view. But Mr. Trump made clear he feels that any firm acknowledgement of Russia’s involvement would undermine the legitimacy of his election.
Standing alongside Mr. Putin, Mr. Trump steered clear of any confrontation with the Russian, going so far as to question American intelligence and last week’s federal indictments that accused 12 Russians of hacking into Democratic email accounts to hurt Hillary Clinton in 2016.
“I have great confidence in my intelligence people, but I will tell you that President Putin was extremely strong and powerful in his denial today.
“He just said it’s not Russia. I will say this: I don’t see any reason why it would be,” Mr. Trump said.
His skepticism drew a quick formal statement — almost a rebuttal — from Mr. Trump’s director of
national Intelligence, Dan Coats. “We have been clear in our assessments of Russian meddling in the 2016 election and their ongoing, pervasive efforts to undermine our democracy, and we will continue to provide unvarnished and objective intelligence in support of our national security,” Mr. Coats said.
Fellow GOP politicians have generally stuck with Mr. Trump during a year and a half of turmoil, but he was assailed as seldom before as he returned home Monday night from what he had hoped would be a proud summit with Mr. Putin.
Sen. John McCain of Arizona was most outspoken, declaring that Mr. Trump made a “conscious choice to defend a tyrant” and achieved “one of the most disgraceful performances by an American president in memory.” House Speaker Paul Ryan, who rarely criticizes Mr. Trump, stressed there was “no question” that Russia had interfered.
Even staunch Trump backer Newt Gingrich, the former House speaker, called Mr. Trump’s comments “the most serious mistake of his presidency” and said they “must be corrected — immediately.”
Former CIA Director John Brennan, who served under former President Barack Obama, called Mr. Trump’s words “nothing short of treasonous.” Mr. Brennan tweeted: “Not only were Trump’s comments imbecilic, he is wholly in the pocket of Putin. Republican Patriots: Where are you???”
In a Fox News Channel interview after the summit, Mr. Putin pronounced the meetings “the beginning of the path” back from the West’s past efforts to isolate Russia. “I think you see for yourself that these efforts failed, and they were never bound to succeed,” he said.
As he flew home to Washington aboard Air Force One, Mr. Trump tried to clarify his position via tweet, saying: “As I said today and many times before, ‘I have GREAT confidence in MY intelligence people.’ However, I also recognize that in order to build a brighter future, we cannot exclusively focus on the past - as the world’s two largest nuclear powers, we must get along!”
In an interview with Fox News’ Sean Hannity that aired later Monday, Mr. Trump said “it’s a shame” that he and Mr. Putin were being asked questions about the Russia probe while they were trying to discuss issues like Syria and nuclear proliferation. “We’ve had a phony witch hunt deal drive us apart,” he said.
In their totality, Mr. Trump’s remarks were viewed as amounting to an unprecedented embrace of a man who for years has been isolated by the U.S. and Western allies for actions in Ukraine, Syria and beyond. And it came at the end of an extraordinary trip to Europe in which Mr. Trump had already berated allies, questioned the value of the NATO alliance and demeaned leaders including Germany’s Angela Merkel and Britain’s Theresa May.
The two leaders’ longawaited summit began with a private face-to-face sitdown — just the leaders and their interpreters — that lasted more than two hours, before additional meetings joined by senior aides.
The pair had held lengthy talks before — on the sidelines of world leader meetings in Germany and Vietnam last year — but this was their first official summit and was being watched closely, especially following the announcement Friday of new indictments against 12 Russian intelligence officers accused of hacking Democratic emails to help Mr. Trump’s campaign.
Asked about the indictments, Mr. Putin suggested that Moscow and Washington could jointly conduct the investigation, inviting special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigators to come to Russia to interview the 12 people — an idea Mr. Trump hailed as an “incredible offer.”
Mr. Putin said he’d expect the U.S. to return the favor and cooperate in the Russian probe against William Browder, a British investor charged with financial crimes in Russia. Mr. Browder, an outspoken Putin critic, was a driving force behind a U.S. law targeting Russian officials over human rights abuses.
The summit began just hours after Mr. Trump blamed the United States — and not Russian election meddling or its annexation of Crimea — for a low-point in U.S.-Russia relations.
“Our relationship with Russia has NEVER been worse,” Mr. Trump tweeted Monday morning, blaming “many years of U.S. foolishness and stupidity and now, the Rigged Witch Hunt!”
The Russian foreign ministry responded by liking Mr. Trump’s tweet and then replying, “We agree.”
Asked whether Russia was responsible at all, Mr. Trump said “we’re all to blame” for the soured relations.
However, “that changed,” he said, “as of about four hours ago.”
Mr. Putin ridiculed as “sheer nonsense” allegations that Russian intelligence agencies had collected compromising information on Mr. Trump during his visit to Moscow years before the election, saying that he had no idea Mr. Trump was even visiting.
Mr.Trump also dismissed the idea in his interview with Mr. Hannity, adding, “If they had it, it would have been out.”
Still, Mr. Putin said he had indeed wanted Mr. Trump to win the election — a revelation that might have made more headlines if not for Mr. Trump’s performance — but had taken no action to make it happen.
“Yes, I wanted him to win because he spoke of normalization of Russian-U.S. ties,” Mr. Putin said. “Isn’t it natural to feel sympathy to a person who wanted to develop relations with our country? It’s normal.”
At the closing press conference, Mr. Putin, riding high after hosting a successful World Cup, unveiled a gift he’d brought for Mr. Trump: a red and white soccer ball, which he tossed to Mr. Trump at the neighboring lectern. Mr. Trump passed it over to his wife, and said they’d give it to their soccer-loving 12-yearold son, Barron.
Out on the streets, the summit attracted a grab-bag of protesters, with abortionrights activists wearing artificially bulging bellies and Trump masks, anti-fascist protesters bearing signs with expletive-laden insults, and free traders, anti-war Ukrainians and gay rights supporters making their voices heard.