Whales go quiet and dolphins shout in loud oceans
Studies show noises disrupt and stress marine mammals
The oceans are loud and getting louder all the time. And marine mammals must live in the din. These animals take different approaches to the noise: Dolphins perform the equivalent of shouting. Humpback whales, when competing with a nearby boat, go silent.
“A lot of people imagine that underwater is this really quiet place, but it isn’t,” said biologist Helen Bailey, who studies marine mammals and sea turtles at the University of Maryland. Ocean sounds are more than just crashing waves. Sharp noises, like sonar used in oil exploration or explosive Navy war games, can damage whale ears. Busy cargo lanes thrum with ship traffic. And as the Arctic warms, allowing more ships and industrial developments in previously ice-locked regions, northern marine mammal populations are exposed to more noise.
Increasing ocean noise was identified as a potential problem more than 20 years ago. Near California, the loudness of ship traffic has roughly doubled each decade since the 1960s. But the specific effects of this human-made cacophony are still being pieced together.
Ms. Bailey and her colleagues, in a report published Tuesday in the journal Biology Letters, used underwater microphones to listen to bottlenose dolphins about 20 miles offshore from Ocean City, Md. The scientists recorded 77 different animals, who distinguished themselves by their “signature whistles,” Ms. Bailey said. The ability to identify wild dolphins by their whistles rather than relying on visual markings, is a new and powerful development in research, Ms. Bailey said.
Sound is a cornerstone of dolphin society. Their calls convey important identity information, and they might even use whistles while foraging to alert others to the presence of fish. Dolphins form what Ms. Bailey described as “fission-fusion” societies, weaving in and out of social bands. As this happens, it’s “sort of like a family gathering, talking all over each other,” Ms. Bailey said. “They’re very vocal and they like to chat.”
When the background sea noise — the ambient sounds of the offshore shipping lanes, which sounds something like loud radio static — began to crescendo, the dolphins used information-poor whistles, Ms. Bailey and her co-authors found. The contours of their calls became flat, rather than the richer, curvier whistles.
It’s been known that human-made noise can mask animal calls, as long as the frequencies overlap. But in the new study “this adjustment wasn’t just to noise in the same frequency as their calls,” Ms. Bailey said. That surprised her and her co-authors. “We were making assumptions that just weren’t true,” she said. “We have to think a little bit differently about how noise is impacting these animals.”
Janet Mann, an expert in bottlenose dolphins at Georgetown University who was not involved with this research, said that she suspects that calves would stay near their mothers while ambient sounds are loud. Otherwise, they might risk permanent separation. “This means the calf has fewer opportunities to explore the environment or develop bonds on its own,” Ms. Mann said.
Only a few studies have examined the effects of ambient sounds like this one. “Navy research on the impact of sound on marine mammals involves controlled studies with loud sounds where the animals are being observed and recorded,” Ms. Mann said. “Ambient noise from shipping is ever-present, and it is hard to do controlled research.”
Another study, published in 2012, examined a relative period of ambient quiet, when ship traffic ceased after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Along with a 6 dB decrease in noise, stress hormones dropped in the feces of North Atlantic right whales. This suggests that “when ambient noise dropped precipitously, the whales were far less stressed,” Ms. Mann said.
Halfway across the globe from Maryland, in Japan, researchers recently monitored humpback whales near a remote shipping lane. Two recorders captured the sounds of the cargo liner and nearby whales. When the ship passed by, “humpback whales seemed to stop singing temporarily,” the study authors reported in their study published Wednesday in PLOS One.
This paper was unusual because “there are not so many studies based on a direct and quantitative approach,” said Sadaharu Koga, a chief scientist at the Japan Ship Technology Research Association. It is unclear how damaging the cetaceans’ cessations are, but previous studies show that “singing behavior is related to the breeding strategies of male whales,” Mr. Koga said. Songs are a way for males to advertise their presence and attract females.
“The water is a perfect medium for conducting sound, which is great if you are a fin whale that needs to find a mate 100 miles away,” Ms. Mann said, “but not so great if there are loud human-made sounds that interfere with your attempts to find a date.”
In 2016, the Obama White House directed the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration to create high-level guidelines to reduce ocean noise. NOAA finalized its road map in September 2016. NOAA’s Ocean Noise Strategy is a “10-year vision” to understand and manage ocean noise, said Jason Gedamke, manager of the agency’s Fisheries Ocean Acoustics Program.
NOAA has already established a Noise Reference Station Network, which comprises 12 monitoring sites across U.S. waters, and a Passive Acoustic Data Archive that includes map where the public can observe the location of data collection sites.
But there are no rules for marine sounds comparable to those that limit noise pollution on land, Ms. Bailey said. Specific noisy activities, like an oil company’s seismic survey, might require a permit. For general boat noise, though, “there are no regulations,” she said. “If we can make everything” — like ship engines, she said — “just a little bit quieter then we can reduce this problem.”