Herbivores face highest risk of extinction, scientists say

Although scientists often worry most about the loss of the world’s predators, a comprehensive new study finds that plant-eating herbivores are the animals most at risk of extinction.

About one in four species of herbivores, 25.5%, are considered threatened, endangered or vulnerable by the International Union for Conservation of Nature — IUCN — the world’s scientific authority on extinction risk, according to a study in Wednesday’s journal Science Advances.

By comparison, 17.4% of the predators and 15.8% of omnivores were at risk, said study lead author Trisha Atwood, an ecologist at Utah State University.

Researchers analyzed data for 22,166 species of animals with backbones, including the type of animal (reptile, bird or mammal), geographic location, habitat and size. And in just about every way examined, they found planteaters were the most at risk, especially in forest ecosystems.

“The implications for this are huge,” Ms. Atwood said. “We need to think about herbivores as being kind of the poster child of extinction.”

So instead of polar bears and tigers, think of planteaters like rhinos and green sea turtles, Ms. Atwood said. The last male northern white rhinoceros in the wild died in 2018, but scientists are attempting to save the species with donor embryos.

The study focused on proportionality, not raw numbers of species at risk. There are many more predator species, so there are more vulnerable predators in total, but a larger share of herbivores are in trouble.

Scientists examined the presumed diets of more than 2,000 species no longer alive and found that herbivores again had the highest extinction proportion.

Ms. Atwood went into the study thinking that the predators were most at risk. However, she said the data pointed clearly at herbivores.

Predators, she added, also are in trouble, but not as much as herbivores they often eat.

Extinction causes — invasive species, climate change and habitat loss — hit herbivores harder than animals with other diets, Ms. Atwood said.

Ben Curtis/Associated Press Female northern white rhinos Fatu, 19, right, and Najin, 30, the last two of the species on the planet, are fed carrots by a ranger in their enclosure at Ol Pejeta Conservancy, Kenya, in August 2019. The last male in the wild died in 2018.