Struggling British music clubs face permanent closures
LONDON — When Keiron Marshall was 15, he found his way out of a desperate situation with help from an unexpected source: Eric Clapton.
The guitar great was the host at the first gig Mr. Marshall ever went to, and he was joined on stage by Gary Brooker of Procol Harum, The Who’s Pete Townshend and Beatle Ringo Starr.
Since then, London’s music scene has been a life raft for Mr. Marshall, a musician who now runs a group of small concert venues with his wife. Growing up in south London, he’d endured racial slurs and regular beatings because of his Pakistani heritage. His uncle was killed in a racially motivated attack; his mother struggled with heroin addiction.
“Music for us is a really personal thing,” said Hannah White, Mr. Marshall’s wife. “It’s been totally lifechanging.”
But the music scene they know and love may soon be unrecognizable because of the coronavirus pandemic, which has plunged the U.K. economy into its worst recession on record.
Live music venues have been forced to shut doors for nearly five months, and scores of them are at imminent risk of permanent closure. According to the charity Music Venue Trust, which represents 670 grassroots venues, more than 400 across the country are in crisis.
One of those is Mr. Marshall and Ms. White’s south London venue group, the Sound Lounge.
The British government announced indoor and socially distanced live music could resume Saturday. But this doesn’t mean the country’s vibrant live music scene will be immediately restored.
“The truth is that actually only 11% of venues will be able to open in a financially viable manner,” said Mark Davyd, founder and CEO of the Music Venue Trust.
Less than a third of venues have the physical space to house safe, socially distanced gigs. And the majority of those would lose too much money on these reduced-capacity shows for it to be economically feasible.
Clubs have already amassed millions of pounds in debts since March, with more expected in the coming months.
“In total, these venues are going to be over 60 million pounds ($78.3 million) in debt” by the end of
September, Mr. Davyd said.
The government announced in late July that 2.25 million pounds ($2.94 million) would be funneled to 150 grassroots venues that would otherwise have been out of cash by the end of September. The fund was the first slice of a 1.57 billionpound ($1.86 billion) “culture recovery package” that was rolled out on July 5.
Mr. Davyd welcomed the emergency fund but cautioned this was just a “short-term fix,” one only aimed at helping “venues identified as being in crisis.”
In total, 500 million pounds ($654 million) of the recovery package has been allocated to cultural institutions that can “demonstrate their international, national or local significance.” Grant applications for this scheme opened Monday, and venues have until Aug. 21 to submit. For a lot of grassroots clubs that have never applied for grants before, the 11-day window is going to be another challenge.
Derek Nash, a veteran saxophonist and member of Jools Holland’s Rhythm & Blues Orchestra, worries about who the recipients of the bailout will ultimately be.
“Let’s not give it all to opera,” Mr. Nash said, adding he wants the funds to go to venues like the 606 Club, a small but popular jazz venue running shows seven nights a week.
At the moment, the 606 Club is surviving off a government loan it qualified for through the Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme. But that has put the club heavily in debt.
“The smaller venues that you come up through, where you kind of learn your trade — those are incredibly important,” said club owner Steve Rubie. “If those venues aren’t there, those musicians aren’t getting a chance to practice and learn their trade. So it’s a really serious issue.”
Meanwhile, the Sound Lounge has stayed afloat with help from friends and crowdfunding. The owners applied for the government’s emergency scheme last week.
“If we can survive it, I think culture, and especially music, is going to have a massive role to play in our recovery,” Ms. White said.
“People need experiences,” she added. “That’s what we all felt in lockdown. It’s not really the stuff or the shopping we missed; it’s human contact. So there’s a massive potential — but we need to be able to survive.”