‘COVID with a vengeance’ consumes U.S. politics
The American political system has come down with a case of long COVID.
In Washington and the states, and in both political parties, expectations that the virus might be routed this summer and make way for some version of politicallife-as-usual have abruptly disintegrated. The resurgence of the disease, driven by the fast-spreading delta variant, threatens to halt plans by both parties to shift their attention to other matters ahead of the midterm elections next year.
President Joe Biden’s hoped-for message that happy days are here again is on hold as the administration’s initially blitzkrieg-like vaccine rollout has slowed to a relative crawl and new debates flare up over public health mandates on inoculation and mask-wearing. There are already fissures in his own party, particularly among labor unions, about how far the government and private businesses should go in requiring employees to take the vaccines.
Even a breakthrough in Senate negotiations last week over a major bipartisan infrastructure deal was crowded in the news by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s reversal of its previous guidance on masking for vaccinated people, and by new vaccine mandates issued by major companies like Google and Facebook and for public employees in states including New York, New Mexico and California.
On Thursday, Mr. Biden took the broadest measures yet to make vaccination or constant testing obligatory for millions of people, including federal workers and military personnel. While he stressed that the country had made great progress since his inauguration in January, Mr. Biden acknowledged that the American escape from the virus had turned into a slog because of the country’s large unvaccinated minority.
“America is divided, between the majority of eligible people who are vaccinated and those who are not,” Mr. Biden said. “And I understand that many of you in the majority are frustrated with the consequences of the failure of the minority to get vaccinated.”
For Mr. Biden’s Republican adversaries, the return of the virus threatens to divert public attention from issues conservatives are eager to campaign on — like crime and inflation — and fix it firmly back on the disease that the Trump administration mishandled with catastrophic consequences.
Hostility to basic mitigation measures among conservative voters and politicians has impeded efforts to contain the virus from the start, and the states where vaccination rates are lowest and new outbreaks are strongest are almost uniformly Republican-leaning. A drawn-out plague disproportionately afflicting red-state America could become an embarrassment for the GOP even as anti-government language on matters of public health becomes an increasingly central strain of Republican messaging.
On Thursday, while Mr. Biden was applauding the Republican Senate leader, Mitch McConnell, of Kentucky, for encouraging people in his home state to take the vaccine, a throng of House Republicans were mounting a rowdy demonstration on Capitol Hill against the reimposition of a mask mandate in the chamber. Vaccination rates in the House vary widely between the parties, with many Republicans flaunting a cavalier attitude toward the illness.
But even for political leaders who are uninterested in the coronavirus, it is clear that the coronavirus is interested in them.
“This week I think it’s become unavoidable for all of us to feel that heat turning up again,” said Amy Acton, the former top health adviser to Ohio’s Republican governor, Mike DeWine. “We are once again approaching some sort of inflection point.”
Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham, of New Mexico, a Democrat, who this week issued a new vaccination requirement for public employees and urged New Mexicans to don masks indoors, said she was “one thousand percent with the president” in his toughenedup approach to vaccine distribution. (She put her own views on the issue more bluntly: “Shame on you if you won’t get vaccinated.”)
Ms. Lujan Grisham, who is the head of the Democratic Governors Association, said she expected the issue of pandemic management to remain “at the heart” of governing and campaigning at the state level through 2022.
“I think absolutely that will be a cornerstone of all these campaigns,” Ms. Lujan Grisham said. “How you responded to COVID, and what impact it had on the economy, will be front and center.”
The midterms
The midterm elections are still a long way off, and it is possible that before the autumn of 2022 the pandemic will shrink somewhat in the nation’s political consciousness.
Mr. Biden’s ambitious legislative agenda is winding its way through Congress, giving the president a chance of trumpeting major successes in 2022 unrelated to the pandemic. Despite the climbing numbers of infections and deaths, the toll is still a fraction of what it was in 2020 before the arrival of multiple highly effective vaccines.
Yet for the moment, it may be difficult to mount a campaign of mass communication on issues that are not tightly bound up with the ongoing public health crisis, including subjects like voting rights and immigration that are high
priorities for Mr. Biden’s party. The complexity of resuming in-person business activities and schooling this fall could grow exponentially if cases continue to climb and vaccination rates do not pick up, potentially vexing parents and employers who are impatient to move on from the strictures of 2020 and early 2021.
In polling conducted by the Democratic opinion-research group Navigator, there have been signs of growing pessimism about the trajectory of the pandemic. In early June, the group found more than seven in 10 voters saying that the worst of the pandemic was in the past. By late July, that figure had slipped to 55%.
Polls have found that Mr. Biden enjoys consistent support from voters for his handling of the coronavirus, and his determination to crush the pandemic was at the core of his successful campaign.
But his administration for months held back from using the most forceful steps available to compel reluctant Americans to take the vaccine, including the promotion of aggressive vaccine mandates or the creation of a vaccine passport of the kinds devised in countries like France and Israel.
Mayor London Breed, of San Francisco, a Democrat who issued a vaccine mandate for public employees more than a month ago, said it had not been an option for localities like her own to wait on federal action. She said she was examining ways to further expand the reach of her vaccination orders, perhaps by imposing mandates on businesses that receive city contracts or grants.
“We need to be decisive. We can’t wait around to see what happens,” Ms. Breed said. “It’s almost like COVID with a vengeance, and we need to make sure that we’re not going backwards.”
The split among Republicans over how to handle the coronavirus was on painful display in Washington recently, as Mr. McConnell issued the latest of many personal pleas for Americans to ignore “bad advice” and get vaccinated, while his counterpart in the House, Kevin McCarthy, of California, fired off a conspiratorial tweet saying that the new CDC masking guidance had been “conjured up by liberal government officials who want to live in a perpetual pandemic state.”
An equally instructive split-screen image came out of a news conference of Senate Republicans on Tuesday: Roy Blunt, of Missouri, a longtime party stalwart who is retiring after his current term, pleaded with Americans to get vaccinated, reading aloud news articles abou tun vaccinated Missourians stricken with the illness. Looking on at his side was Rick Scott, of Florida, the head of the party’s Senate campaign committee, who has introduced legislation banning vaccine passports and, in a Fox Business interview, called declining to be vaccinated a personal choice.
Harnessing discontent
A growing number of Republicans running for high office have tried to harness conservative discontent by pledging their opposition to new mandates, includi n g Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the former White House spokesperson running for governor of Arkansas, who recently simultaneously encouraged voters to take what she called the “Trump vaccine” and vowed not to impose mask or vaccine requirements in office.
Former Gov. Mike Leavitt, of Utah, who served as the federal health secretary in the George W. Bush administration, said the country’s leaders should recognize they were still in the “early days” of the pandemic, as a political matter — a demoralizing warning to those hoping for a light at the end of the tunnel.
After a dozen years of partisan warfare about the structure of the health care system, Mr. Leavitt added, it should be no surprise that a pathogen that has claimed more than 600,000 American lives would yield another version of that debate.
“When you boil it down, it’s the same issue: What role should government play in our lives?” Mr. Leavitt said.
Peter Kauffmann, a Democratic strategist advising Mayor Bill de Blasio on New York City’s response to the pandemic, said it had become tragically clear that much of the country was unwilling to do its part to hasten the end of the pandemic.
“There’s not going to be that ‘aha’ moment that we’re all waiting for,” Mr. Kauffmann said. “Those of us on the responsible wing of the country just have to keep plugging away.”