Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

My mother has dementia

- Tom Butch is the retired president of TD Ameritrade, Inc., and lives with his family outside Pittsburgh.

When I tell acquaintan­ces that my mother is in throes of dementia and living in a memory care facility, they typically react with a sort of fatalistic empathy. And, maybe, within themselves, fear of what might be.

I know their caring is as real as I suspect their dread to be. My mom was substantia­lly defined by her intellect and her successful career on the staff of a U.S. senator. It is a cruel fate that a vibrant mind should be subjected to the metaphoric­al wiping of its hard drive.

We tend — not unkindly by intent, I think — to view people suffering from dementia as less than the whole human they once were.

Dispossess­ed

They can be seen as the zombies of our time, worthy of sympathy but stripped of their humanity. Those with even the most debilitati­ng diseases can still converse, interact, remember. Those with dementia are dispossess­ed of reason, memory and, as such, we conclude, their core selves.

Many people I know question whether it even makes sense for someone in dementia to carry on, and insist that, if it were them, they surely would not want to. As with many things, that’s an easy conclusion as a distant thesis and fails in the light of living.

My mom is, simply, still my mom. Beneath the hard-to-penetrate shell of dementia is the person who put herself through college, twice; survived my dad’s premature death and the resultant need to raise a family solo; earned a distinguis­hed career; stayed steady to her faith.

That person, today, intermitte­ntly surmounts the entrapment of dementia to engage and remember, even shed new light on the past. Just as often, she careens into abstractio­n and not always reconcilab­le derivative­s of her past and present realities.

But always, she is there, perhaps in her purest sense. She exists, today, to receive and return love.

Stripped of pretense, social sensitivit­ies and interperso­nal tensions, she routinely, emphatical­ly, expresses her love and gratitude for her family (whom, yes, amid the confusion, she still recognizes) and wants only to receive the same from us.

More human than us

She is, in that sense, more purely human than most of us, even her past self.

Studies show that people fear dementia more than every disease but cancer. Among those over 65, dementia leapfrogs even cancer. The erosion of cognition scares us even more than the pain and inevitable lifespan-reducing consequenc­es of most physical illnesses.

I guess we understand, and even prefer, the certitude of a death sentence to the ambiguity of memory loss, dissipated intellectu­al capacity and wandering in unmarked corridors of our minds. We think that we surrender more of our true selves in cognitive decline than we do with any purely physical ailment, however critical and painful it may be.

We are, after all, human. And maybe with that fallibilit­y comes our simplified perspectiv­e of those who, through dementia, have in our view become less than fully that. Maybe we just need to look a little harder. Connect with the person who still is there, versus longing for the one who was. Seek whatever reservoir remains intact behind the dam, accept the meandering overflow.

None of the process has been easy. The Kubler Ross Grief Cycle seems to apply as readily to dementia as it does death. Maybe that’s why we so freely, and wrongly, seem to equate the two.

And from onset, when my mom asked the identity of my sister-in-law, whom she knew well, at the end of a Mother’s Day brunch, to finding the right care to the seemingly endless dirge of emptying and selling her condo, it has been a journey of frequent tristesse. But also a bonus round of close interactio­n, healing, and saying what needs said, words less important than their emotional conveyance.

Human moments

Humanity prevails. And many moments are their own treasures. The other day, as I was concluding a visit, my mom — who that day had reflected clearly and accurately on her siblings but later told a disconnect­ed story of a young boy in a gold suit, at the front of a parade line — part of the daily yin and yang of her disease — asked me to pour some more soda into her cup.

“Are you sure you haven’t had enough?” I asked.

“Oh, I have,’ she replied, “but I know if you pour more you will stay while I drink it and I’m not ready for you to leave.”

 ?? Evan Vucci/Associated Press ?? PET scan results are analyzed as part of a study on Alzheimer’s disease at Georgetown University Hospital in Washington.
Evan Vucci/Associated Press PET scan results are analyzed as part of a study on Alzheimer’s disease at Georgetown University Hospital in Washington.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States