Shore relief?
Great Lakes water levels below the peak, but higher than normal for this time of year
Water levels on the Great Lakes are down. But hang onto those sandbags.
“We are tracking below last year but we’re still well above the normal average for this time of year,” says Deanna Apps, physical scientist for the United States Army Corps of Engineers in the Detroit District and lead forecaster for Great Lakes water levels.
“So, we will still need to be prepared for potential flooding and erosion, and remain cautious when boating or recreating along the shorelines.”
Great Lakes levels
The driver of water levels is Mother Nature says Apps.
As explained by the Watershed Council for Northern Michigan, the hydrologic cycle, as it’s also known, determines water supply to the Great Lakes Basin. The cycle is basically water inflow (precipitation, runoff, and water from streams and groundwater) minus water outflow (evaporation and water flowing out of the system) equals a change in lake water levels.
Changes are driven by climatic factors and weather patterns such as precipitation and temperature. For the most part, continuous wet and cold years will cause water levels to rise, while consecutive warm and dry years will cause water levels to decline.
Changes in water levels over long periods of time are usually a result of higher or lower precipitation (rain and snow) and evaporation rates.
Precipitation anywhere in the Great Lakes Basin, whether over the water or somewhere inland, will find its way into the Great Lakes. Increased precipitation will raise their levels. Lower precipitation leads to lower runoff from the Basin causing lake levels to decline. Evaporation draws water from the lakes causing levels to decline. Evaporation occurs most often when the temperature difference between the water and the air is greatest. Such conditions occur in the fall, when the air has cooled but the water still retains some of the heat gained during the summer. If ice cover is not significant, the open water continues to lose vapor to the dry winter air, dropping water levels even more.
A look at the seasons and the cycle shows winter to be the biggest factor in determining Great Lakes water levels. A wet winter with above normal snowfall and bitter cold temperatures creates vast ice cover and causes lake levels to rise, but a mild winter with warmer temperatures and subsequently less ice cover and more evaporation will decrease lake levels.
Lots of rain and snow in the early 1970s and 1980s raised the water levels of the Great Lakes to above average. But they
took a turn again when warm winters with sporadic snowfall resulted in the prolonged period of low water experienced between 1999 and 2014. During the winters of 2017 and 2019, the entire Great Lakes region experienced wet conditions, Apps said, including large amounts of precipitation and bitter cold temperatures that created vast ice cover, snow melt and spring runoff. In 2020, conditions were a little drier but there was still a lot of precipitation earlier in the year says App.
This past winter was not only drier but a great deal warmer than the previous years. Combined with frigid temperatures in February, it caused an increase in evaporation across the lakes and an ice jam on the St. Clair River that caused a considerable amount of flooding along several shoreline communities. However, the water receded once the U.S. Coast Guard cutter Bristol Bay and the Canadian Coast Guard cutters Griffon and Samuel Risley were able to break up the ice jams.
Lower levels
The Army Corps of Engineers reported water levels on all of the Great Lakes to be lower in February.
• Lake Michigan and Huron are reported to be down nearly a foot lower than a year ago.
• Even lower was Lake Ontario, which is now almost 35 inches lower than last year.
• Lake Superior’s water level, which dropped by 3 inches, is currently 9 inches lower than 2020.
• Lake Erie saw a drop of 15 inches, but that could be due to the ice jams that occurred upstream on the St. Clair River.
• Lake St. Clair’s water levels are also lower. In February they were reported to be 11 inches lower than last year at this time but are still 24 inches above average.
“I think water levels are down everywhere,” says Nicki Polan of Oakland County and president of the Michigan Boating Industry Association.
Out of curiosity, Polan did a random survey of family, friends and business associates who have homes or property on inland lakes including Cass, Union, Loon, Brendel and Elizabeth Lake and they all reported levels
to be lower.
“That’s good news for property owners, boaters and anyone else who is negatively affected by the higher waters,” Polan says. .
One who would concur is Macomb County Sheriff Anthony Wickersham. Last year around this time his deputies were building docks on top of docks in order to reach their patrol boats at the Marine Division Office in Harrison Township. The office is nestled on a peninsula on Lake St. Clair. The water was so high that every time there were high southerly winds the waves would crash against the shoreline and threaten the integrity of the marina, boathouse and office. A wall of sandbags held up but it was touch and go for several weeks.
“Right now it looks fine,” says Wickersham. “It’s no longer an emergency situation this year but we’re not going to ignore it but look at a permanent solution for the future.”
The solution includes a new seawall, a covered docking area for the boats, and possibly a new office.
Doug Vosler, who owns Anchor Bay Marina in New Baltimore and has been serving the needs of boaters in southeast Michigan for years, is among those who could not be happier about the lower levels.
“The season has already been great,” Vosler says. “We still have about 600 sandbags in storage if we need them but we’re taking down the preparations we’ve had in place for the high water levels last year.”
Preparations last year included extra docks extended out onto the Salt River, which snakes through a number of canal communities before spilling out into Lake St. Clair.
“Boaters had to deal with a lot of extra circumstances last year,” Vosler said.
Some of the challenges for boaters included not being able to find gas because gas stations had problems with water seeping into their fuel tanks, or traveling to their favorite sandbar or little island for a picnic on the beach, or a drop-anchor party only to find the sandbar had disappeared. Homeowners down the road along the Jefferson Avenue canals and the shoreline of Lake St. Clair also endured several seasons of flooding. A drive along the shore shows a few for-sale signs while others are working to raise their property to combat the water
that follows a wet winter.
Despite the problems of high water levels, Vosler says he was busy during the pandemic due to people’s increased interest in boating and the need for outdoor recreation, and expects this season to be even better.
“People are already putting their boats in the water,” Polan said. ‘My son is already pushing me to get ours ready and it’s not even spring.”
Inland lakes
In general, inland lakes and rivers aren’t entirely immune to rising and falling water levels on the Great Lakes, according to the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy. The department expects water levels on the Great Lakes to continue to trend higher with year-toyear fluctuations. High water levels on the Great Lakes can cause a backwater effect on the rivers that flow into them, in turn backing up into streams, lakes and wetlands upstream, and saturating groundwater. With less places for the water to go, the frequency and magnitude of flooding can increase.
Oakland County has six major watersheds feeding a multitude of inland lakes and streams::
• Clinton River – 83 miles long, 760 square mile watershed draining east into Lake St. Clair.
• Huron River – 130 miles long, 908 square mile watershed draining southwest into Lake Erie.
• Rouge River – 127 miles long, 467 square mile watershed draining into the Detroit River.
• Flint River – 78 miles long, 1,332 square mile watershed emptying north into the Shiawassee River and Saginaw Bay.
• Shiawassee River – 110 miles long, 1,201 square mile watershed draining north into Saginaw Bay.
• Belle River – 73 miles long, 227 square mile watershed emptying south into the St. Clair River at Marine City.
But the portions of the rivers and watersheds in Oakland County are a long way from the parts of the Great Lakes they drain into and are less affected by rising or falling Great Lakes levels.
Jim Nash, water resources commissioner for Oakland County, said it’s not really Great Lakes levels that impact inland lakes, rivers and streams in Oakland County, but the amount of moisture in the ground from wet
weather events.
Depending on who’s doing the estimating, Oakland County has some 1,200 lakes and a couple hundred that are navigable. Some are spring-fed, and some are part of the river systems in the watershed. The water resources commissioner’s office maintains lake levels on 54 of them. Augmentation wells fill them up when conditions are dry and water level structures release water when conditions are wet.
“It’s been fairly dry this spring,” Nash said. “The ground hasn’t been as saturated as in the past two years. I don’t see anything big this year.”