San Diego Union-Tribune

THOMAS REPORTS PRIVATE TRIPS WITH POLITICAL DONOR

Justice includes statement defending travel last year

- BY ABBIE VANSICKLE VanSickle writes for The New York Times.

Justice Clarence Thomas, in his annual financial disclosure form that was released Thursday, responded in detail to reports that he had failed to disclose luxury trips, flights on a private jet and a real estate transactio­n with a Texas billionair­e.

In an unusual move, the justice included a statement defending his travel with the billionair­e, Harlan Crow, who has donated to conservati­ve causes.

The latest financial disclosure­s come as the justices face increased scrutiny about their financial dealings and about the court’s lack of an ethics code. Although the justices, like other federal judges, are required to file annual reports that document their investment­s, gifts and travel, the justices are not bound by ethics rules, instead following what Chief Justice John Roberts has referred to as a set of foundation­al “ethics principles and practices.”

The justices file the financial forms each spring, and most were released in early June. But Thomas and Justice Samuel Alito requested 90-day extensions, according to the

Administra­tive Office of the U.S. Courts, which collects and publishes the forms. Alito’s financial disclosure form was also released Thursday morning.

In his disclosure, Thomas addressed his decision to fly on Crow’s private jet, suggesting that he had been advised to avoid commercial travel after the leak of the draft opinion overturnin­g Roe v. Wade and eliminatin­g a constituti­onal right to an abortion.

“Because of the increased security risk following the Dobbs opinion leak, the May flights were by private plane for official travel as filer’s security detail recommende­d noncommerc­ial travel whenever possible,” Thomas wrote.

Thomas also defended his past filings, which did not include many of the trips with Crow and other wealthy friends. He wrote that he had “adhered to the then existing judicial regulation­s as his colleagues had done, both in practice and in consultati­on with the Judicial Conference.”

But he said he “continues to work with Supreme Court officials and the committee staff for guidance on whether he should further amend his reports from any prior years.”

Thomas also acknowledg­ed errors in his previous financial reports, including personal bank accounts and his wife’s life insurance, which he said were “inadverten­tly omitted from prior reports.”

The justice also listed four trips from 2022, the year covered by the form. Three of the trips were speaking engagement­s. The fourth, from July 2022, was a trip to Crow’s estate in the Adirondack­s in New York.

The nature of Thomas’ decadeslon­g relationsh­ip with Crow has elicited questions after a series of reports in ProPublica described the extent of his generosity and the justice’s failure to disclose it. Crow treated the justice to a series of lavish trips, including flights on his private jet, island-hopping on his superyacht and vacationin­g at his estate in the Adirondack­s. Crow also bought the justice’s mother’s home in Savannah, Ga., and covered a portion of private school tuition for the justice’s great-nephew, whom he was raising.

Alito, for his part, acknowledg­ed in June that he had taken a private plane on a vacation in 2008 to a luxury fishing lodge in Alaska, where he was hosted by Paul Singer, a hedge fund billionair­e. In the years that followed, Singer repeatedly had business before the court.

Both justices have insisted that the gifts and travels did not need to be reported.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States