Refugee’s dreams turned to distress
Ethiopian killed by officer saw life unravel in Oakland
A man shot and killed by an Oakland police officer in August left behind only a small pile of luggage and a few family photographs, one of which had a phone number scrawled on the back.
The number belonged to the 30-year-old man’s mother, Genet Alemu, who sells injera bread to support a family of seven in Ethiopia. She last heard from her son, Yonas Alehegne, several months before his death.
“I feel like I’m dead,” Alemu said from her village in Dire Dawa, where she lives in a house that her other son, Habtamu, describes as “almost a tent.” Alemu was reached by phone Sept. 12 — the day of the Ethiopian new year. Dawn had broken and a rooster crowed insistently in the background.
Remembering “Yonas,” Alemu wailed.
“He was my first son,” she said, speaking through an interpreter in Amharic, the language spoken in Ethiopia. “He came to the U.S. to help us.”
Whatever dreams and ambitions Alehegne had when he arrived in the United States in 2012 were soon replaced by distress and desperation.
African refugee
A refugee from political persecution in his home country, Alehegne hoped to find better employment and a means to send remittances back home. But, once here, he exhibited signs of mental illness, and apparently never got treatment. Interviews with family in Ethiopia, people who knew him in the United States and a review of his criminal record and probation report reveal a man who behaved in bizarre and violent ways, became homeless, got into criminal trouble and grew alienated from the systems that might have helped. Toward the end, he desperately wanted to return to Africa.
On Aug. 27, Alehegne was shot dead by Officer Jennifer Farrell on the 200 block of MacArthur Boulevard, after police say he bludgeoned her with a metal chain. He had been sleeping in the laundry room of an apartment complex, and Farrell had been called to investigate reports that Alehegne had assaulted a resident in the building’s garage. Farrell confronted Alehegne when he stepped into the street in front of her police car. When she got out of her car, police say, he struck her with the chain.
Farrell fired several shots, killing Alehegne.
“I knew it was him before they told me,” said Rebecca Lakew, a former office manager at the Ethiopian Community Cultural Center, an Oakland organization that Alehegne would often visit, asking for money and food and begging for help so that he could return home to Ethiopia.
Lakew said the center offered to buy Alehegne a plane ticket home, shortly before his death. But he never filled out the necessary paper“When work.
“We tried our best,” she said. “Maybe we should have tried harder.”
While some worry that the Ethiopian community failed Alehegne, others say the U.S. government should have done more to help him.
“He would have been saved if he had received proper treatment and medications,” said Tadios Belay, executive director of the Horn of Africa Human Rights Network. Belay helped set up a GoFundMe page to raise money to send Alehegne’s body back to Ethiopia and pay for funeral expenses. He is seeking the power of attorney to file a wrongful death suit against Oakland police, on behalf of Alehegne’s family.
Seeking a way out
Born to a father who served as a soldier for the Derg, a communist regime that ruled Ethiopia until 1987, Alehegne dropped out of school after seventh grade to become a day laborer, according to his brother Habtamu, who spoke to The Chronicle by phone from Ethiopia through an interpreter. Unable to find consistent work, and denied opportunities because his tribe, the Amhara, was an ethnic minority in the region, Alehegne fled Ethiopia for neighboring Djibouti when he was 18 or 19.
Alehegne left his home city of Dire Dawa on foot and walked across the border to a refugee camp, Habtamu said, traveling a distance of some 150 miles. He told family members he was assaulted along the way, claiming that strangers bit him.
he was at home, he was fine,” Habtamu said, adding that the journey left Alehegne traumatized. When he called home, Habtamu said, “he would ask me to pray for him.”
The U.S. State Department admitted Alehegne into the United States in 2012 under stepped up efforts by the Obama administration to increase the number of refugees from Africa, in response to sectarian violence, persecution, famine and human trafficking. Alehegne was one of 820 Ethiopian refugees who arrived in the U.S. in 2012, up from 594 in 2011. He would have undergone an intense screening process to be accepted into the refugee program.
“There’s a screening process, fact-checking, and corroborating people’s identities,” said Chris Boian, spokesman for the Office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees in Washington. All who enter a refugee camp have to undergo an exhaustive series of interviews — including psychological screenings — to determine whether they will successfully assimilate into a new host country.
Vetting process
“It’s a constant process of prioritizing and looking for the very most vulnerable individuals,” Boian said.
Only after completing that screening process could Alehegne have applied to resettle in the United States, at which point he would have had to pass security checks, an in-person Department of Homeland Security interview and a medical exam.
Esayas Gezahegne, an Ethiopian refugee who works for the nonprofit Horn of Africa Human Rights Network in Oakland and is familiar with the screening process, said Alehegne could not have passed had he shown signs of a mental illness.
“I’m quite sure no,” he said.
Life in America
According to probation reports, Alehegne touched down in New York in 2012 but left almost immediately for Kentucky, where he lived with a friend while working short-term jobs as a parking attendant and custodian. He obtained a residency card during that time and worked at a Walmart in 2013, according to his former attorney Randy Baker.
Yet, better employment evidently didn’t beget a better life. After Alehegne resettled in the United States, he routinely sent money home, Alemu said, but his mental health began to deteriorate. Baker said Alehegne saw several doctors who said he suffered from mental illness. But Alehegne told probation officers that he couldn’t recall the diagnosis, and never took medications to treat it, Baker said.
He moved to the Bay Area in 2014, unemployed and on his own. And he quickly ran into trouble that summer when four men beat him up on a street and broke his nose. He was staying in a respite wing of the East Oakland Community Project homeless shelter that August, healing from the attack, when, according to authorities, he followed a shelter employee into a bathroom she was cleaning and began undoing his pants, yelling at her to “shut up.” She screamed and others came to her aid, but later that night, Alehegne followed her into and through a BART train, laughing at her distress, authorities said.
Alehegne was arrested and convicted of threatening and stalking the woman, then sentenced to 16 months in state prison.
Alehegne’s English was so limited that on the day of the offense, an interpreter had to tell him he’d been kicked out of the homeless shelter. Another shelter resident, Vernon Wiley, would testify in court later that Alehegne tended to mimic “jibber jabber” he heard on the radio, but couldn’t communicate beyond that.
“He may not have had the wherewithal to access what services we have,” Charles Jameson, the Oakland attorney who represented Alehegne, said.
On the streets
Alehegne served time at San Quentin State Prison and was released in May, having served only part of his sentence. By then he had become increasingly addled, said Fikre Atnafe, another Ethiopian immigrant living in Oakland who saw Alehegne hanging around Lake Merritt shortly after his release, and tried to help.
“He was on the streets, Atnafe said, adding: “He was extremely traumatized by the police.”
In July, an Oakland police officer found Alehegne plucking the feathers from a decapitated goose by Lake Merritt. Alehegne told the officer he was hungry and intended to eat the goose. The officer stunned him with a Taser after Alehegne refused to obey commands.
He was sent to John George Psychiatric Hospital in San Leandro for an evaluation, then transferred to Santa Rita Jail, charged with cruelty to an animal and resisting arrest.
“You gotta know, this guy came from a different part of the world,” Atnafe said, suggesting that Alehegne’s mental illness, compounded by a language barrier, invited misunderstanding.
Calls to his parole agent were forwarded to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. An agency spokesman declined to comment.
A small vigil
On a recent Saturday, Atnafe joined about two dozen other people for a vigil in memory of Alehegne. It was held at Van Buren Avenue and MacArthur Boulevard in Oakland, near the laundry room where Alehegne slept.
Atnafe hung an Ethiopian flag on a telephone wire and lit candles beneath it as others passed out slices of spicy anebabero bread to commemorate the New Year.
The vigil’s organizer, Ash Ashebe, passed out flyers with Alehegne’s photograph. It showed the man with a long, narrow face and searing brown eyes who came to the United States for refuge and wound up dying in the street.
For now, his remains are being held by the Alameda County coroner’s office. But Benyam Mulugeta, board president of the Oakland’s Ethiopian Orthodox Church, believes it isn’t too late to grant Alehegne’s last wish: to go home.