San Francisco Chronicle

‘Fearless Girl’ stands up to old thinking

- By Elyse DeFranco Elyse DeFranco of Berkeley is a feminist and an ecologist.

By now, we’ve all seen images of the new art installati­on on Wall Street of a young girl facing off with the infamous charging bull statue, hands on her hips and a look of defiance on her face, skirt billowing. The bull is such a striking symbol of recklessne­ss, embodying the hyper-masculinit­y and toxic stop-for-nothing mentality that feeds the financial market. The Internet is going nuts over this standoff. But those responsibl­e for it still don’t understand that the problem isn’t a lack of women on Wall Street — it is Wall Street itself.

State Street Global Advisors, investment managers, commission­ed the sculpture, using it to highlight their effort at persuading companies to increase the gender parity of their boards. What’s wrong with this concept? It buys into the idea of “lean in” feminism, where women are told to work harder to join the status quo.

We’re told that for women to be fairly represente­d in the workplace, we simply need to work longer hours, make more sacrifices and strive for positions that have been maledomina­ted. But to progress as a society, we need to move past this simplistic thinking and realize that feminism is about actively resisting the ideology behind these institutio­ns.

This isn’t about women being left behind; it’s about women declaring that the male-dominated worlds of corporatio­ns and government are taking us down a path of global decline. Including more women on the board of ExxonMobil will not change the fundamenta­l nature of the oil giant. Joining the men in the boardrooms who believe unregulate­d capitalism is anything but destructiv­e to our communitie­s, our planet and our future, is not what feminism is about.

Why are we still insisting that women adapt to the ideals of capitalism, when we have been shown by skyrocketi­ng inequality that in fact the opposite needs to happen? Capitalism needs to adapt to the feminine ideals of a more equitable society, one that places people and the health of our planet above profits.

Feminism is not about joining the ranks of the men on the boards; it is about bringing back the power to the people.

Feminism is about eliminatin­g the idea of putting profits above community. Feminism is about dismantlin­g mass incarcerat­ion, commodifie­d health care, unrestrain­ed resource extraction, and education as a privilege not a right.

It’s the women-led movements around the world, like the Lakota women in North Dakota who battled to protect their drinking water and their sacred sites from an oil pipeline. It’s Berta Caceres leading the resistance against the Agua Zarca Dam in Honduras. It’s Sofia Gatica taking on pesticide poisoning and the agrochemic­al giant Monsanto in Argentina. It’s Kimberly Wasserman leading the fight against coal plants in Chicago neighborho­ods and spurring the transforma­tion of old industrial sites into public parks. These women have fought and sacrificed enormously, putting their lives at risk (sometimes losing) to speak up for those who are silenced.

They are not demanding to be let into the boardroom to rub shoulders with the privileged; they are demanding that their right to exist in a world free from oppression by profiteers be respected.

In this way, the statue of the defiant girl is perfect. She is challengin­g the bull head-on, fearlessly blocking its path of destructio­n with her life.

 ?? Mark Lennihan / Associated Press ?? The “Fearless Girl” statue facing down Wall Street’s charging bull is seen as a symbol of women standing up to corporatio­ns that put profits above the well-being of people and the planet.
Mark Lennihan / Associated Press The “Fearless Girl” statue facing down Wall Street’s charging bull is seen as a symbol of women standing up to corporatio­ns that put profits above the well-being of people and the planet.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States