San Francisco Chronicle

Blackouts: Why we need microgrids

Bundling solar panels, batteries provides backup

- By Peter Asmus Peter Asmus is a principal research analyst with Navigant Research. He has been covering energ y issues for over 25 years: www.peterasmus.com.

The blackout that struck San Francisco last Friday, knocking out power for 88,000 customers of Pacific Gas & Electric, may be an isolated event. Yet the incident should serve as a reminder of the effects blackouts impose. With extreme climate change, terrorism and earthquake­s on the horizon, is there something San Francisco can do to make it through such events?

New cleaner energy technologi­es, such as solar panels and advanced batteries, can be bundled together with other energy sources into a “microgrid.” Microgrids are the answer to bolstering the resiliency of crucial public and private energy infrastruc­ture.

What is a microgrid? It is what is sounds like: a small power grid. But when the larger utility grid goes down, a microgrid keeps running. Absent a microgrid, solar panels shut off like the rest of the grid, rendered useless when they could be providing the highest value.

The traditiona­l solution to blackouts for utility customers has been diesel generators. But these energy sources are the most polluting of all. As Easterners will tell, many also failed during Superstorm Sandy in 2012. California’s clean-air and climate-change regulation­s limit diesel fuel burning. In contrast, microgrids can incorporat­e existing diesel generators, but also integrate batteries — which like solar panels keep dropping in price — to provide emergency power while also reducing pollution.

Since 2011, a parade of East Coast states, including New York, have launched funding programs for microgrids. According to Navigant Research, more than 100 microgrids are operating or in the works in California. State agencies such as the California Energy Commission are developing a road map to further commercial­ize microgrids, an emerging industry that has attracted large industrial giants such as GE, Siemens and ABB, as well as Silicon Valley startups and local battery storage innovators such as Sunverge and Advanced Microgrid Solutions.

Military bases, hospitals and communitie­s see value in improving the resilience of regional power grids. Since 1980, the United States has sustained more than 144 weather disasters with damages reaching or exceeding $1 billion each. The total cost of these outages exceeds $1 trillion, according to the U.S. Department of Commerce.

For the Bay Area, whose economy hinges on the likes of Google, Facebook and Apple, a single power outage could cost $1 million per company per outage.

And what would happen if an earthquake the magnitude of the one that hit San Francisco in 1906 struck again? A project developed by the City and County of San Francisco’s Department of the Environmen­t asked that very question. While 96 percent of the city’s consumers could expect their electricit­y to be back online within one week, it could take six months for the natural gas infrastruc­ture to be fully operationa­l.

After a mapping exercise located potential critical facilities in San Francisco that could serve as emergency shelters during such a cataclysmi­c event, a dozen projects relying on solar and battery systems were identified. So far, funding for initial groundwork has come from a $1.2 million grant from the U.S. Department of Energy.

The blackout last week should light a fire under this program, bringing these microgrids on line sooner rather than later (or too late).

 ?? Natasha Dangond / The Chronicle ?? A blackout last week left 88,000 customers without power in San Francisco.
Natasha Dangond / The Chronicle A blackout last week left 88,000 customers without power in San Francisco.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States