San Francisco Chronicle

Misconduct charge for S.F. prosecutor

- By Evan Sernoffsky

The State Bar of California has charged a top San Francisco homicide prosecutor with misconduct related to a 2013 murder case he tried while working for the Solano County district attorney’s office, officials said Monday.

Andrew Ganz, 40, was charged in State Bar court with six counts of misconduct, including intentiona­lly suppressin­g evidence and violating the defendant’s constituti­onal rights. He has 25 days to respond to the State Bar’s notice of disciplina­ry charges. If found culpable, he could face discipline ranging from probation or suspension to disbarment.

Officials with the San Francisco district attorney’s office, where Ganz currently works, would not say if he was still prosecutin­g cases, citing it as a personnel matter.

“We are aware of the State Bar’s filing and will be monitoring the developmen­ts of this case,” said Max Szabo, a spokesman for San Francisco District Attorney George Gascón.

Efforts to reach Ganz, who was admitted to the State Bar in 2004, and his attorney were not immediatel­y successful.

The charges stem from the murder case against Michael Daniels, who was accused of killing his 37-year-old girlfriend, Jessica Brastow, in August 2012.

Daniels, 65, was found not guilty in the case, which was allegedly tainted by Ganz’s contact with the forensic pathologis­t who handled the autopsy.

On Jan. 10, 2013, prosecutor­s presented the pathologis­t, Dr. Susan Hogan, with their theory that Brastow had been murdered. They believed Daniels tied her up in a hotel room and suffocated her with a sock.

Hogan, though, determined the death was by asphyxiati­on, and said it was possible Brastow choked on her own vomit

while drunk. Brastow’s blood alcohol content was a staggering 0.37, and Hogan told prosecutor­s she would not list the death as a homicide.

Despite the conversati­on, Hogan “falsely testified” during Daniels’ preliminar­y hearing that she never met with prosecutor­s and “thought the manner of death was most likely a homicide and the victim was smothered,” Donald Steedman, assistant chief trial counsel for the State Bar, wrote in court papers.

Ganz also failed to correct Hogan’s testimony during the hearing, Steedman wrote, and he later tried to get the defense to take a plea bargain without telling them about his conversati­on with Hogan.

Before the trial started, the judge in the case said Ganz failed to disclose the meeting and the possible exculpator­y material to Daniels’ defense attorneys.

Ganz displayed a “prosecutor­ial attitude either incapable of or disinteres­ted in maintainin­g the minimum ethical standards that all prosecutor­s are sworn to uphold,” Judge Daniel Healy wrote in 2014.

Hogan retired in 2013 amid questions about her competence in other homicide cases.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States