San Francisco Chronicle

What’s the word? Don’t tell me — I’ll think of it

- By Judith Martin, Nicholas Ivor Martin and Jacobina Martin Send questions to Miss Manners’ website: www.missmanner­s.com; to her email address: dearmissma­nners@gmail.com; or through postal mail: Miss Manners, Universal Uclick, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City

Dear Miss Manners: My husband says that when someone is struggling to think of the word they want to say, it is impolite to suggest the word one thinks they may be trying to remember. He says it shows that one thinks one is superior, and that it derails the other person’s thoughts.

I will agree that someone who waits a fraction of a second before volleying the other person with a halfdozen synonyms can be annoying and derail the conversati­on. However, I often feel grateful when someone who has seen me struggle for the right word for a few seconds gently recommends one.

My question is not whether it is rude for me to help my husband find the correct word when he’s having difficulty thinking of it. Obviously, persisting in doing something the other person finds annoying is rude.

Rather, my question is whether it is always rude. Should I try to break myself of this habit with everyone, rather than just him? Gentle Reader: That one should not continue to annoy one’s spouse is, Miss Manners agrees, a good rule. And yours happens to be right — except in regard to consenting spouses. Perhaps you know what it feels like when your device starts supplying words that you had not intended to type.

Anticipati­ng what others want to say is generally demeaning, as it suggests that they are not worth listening to, because you already know what they are taking too much time to say.

However, Miss Manners knows several couples who encourage prompting, especially in regard to shared experience­s or memories. “It was when we were at, uh …” one will say, shooting a look at the other.

“He’s Googling me,” explained a lady of Miss Manners’ acquaintan­ce as she supplied her husband with a name. Dear Miss Manners: My child died, and I am very slowly sending handwritte­n notes to people who came to his memorial service, sent a handwritte­n card, visited or were otherwise comforting. I believe this is proper etiquette, and it is helping me in various ways.

For the 45 or so people who brought us food, do we need to send a thankyou note? Some people have said that it would not be expected and, in fact, to expect it would be placing the very kind of burden on bereaved parents that these people sought to alleviate. Gentle Reader: And yet you say that writing to people who showed that they cared is helping you.

Miss Manners is not surprised. To be able to do something on behalf of your beloved is often sustaining to the bereaved, who may be hit hardest when there is nothing more to be done. Some are able to keep themselves going by becoming involved in a related cause, such as combating the fatal disease or crime.

Please write those letters. Good people who cared about your loss deserve to be encouraged and may be a continuing source of emotional support.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States