San Francisco Chronicle

Police cases: The justices decline to hear cases on whether officers can be held financiall­y responsibl­e for wrongdoing.

- By Jessica Gresko Jessica Gresko is an Associated Press writer.

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court is for now declining to get involved in an ongoing debate by citizens and in Congress over policing, rejecting cases Monday that would have allowed the justices to revisit when police can be held financiall­y responsibl­e for wrongdoing.

With protests over racism and police brutality continuing nationwide, the justices turned away more than half a dozen cases involving the legal doctrine known as qualified immunity, which the high court created more than 50 years ago. It shields officials, including police, from lawsuits for money as a result for things they do in the course of their job.

As is usual, the court didn’t comment in turning away the cases, but Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a sixpage dissent saying he would have agreed to hear one of them.

“I have previously expressed my doubts about our qualified immunity jurisprude­nce,” he wrote, explaining he believes the court’s “qualified immunity doctrine appears to stray from the statutory text.”

As a result of qualified immunity, even when a court finds that an official or officer has violated someone’s constituti­onal rights, they can still be protected from civil lawsuits seeking money. The Supreme Court has said that qualified immunity protects officials as long as their actions don’t violate clearly establishe­d law or constituti­onal rights that they should have known about.

The Supreme Court’s decision not to wade into the qualified immunity debate follows nationwide protests against racism and police brutality sparked by the death in Minnesota of George Floyd in police custody.

In Congress, a bill introduced by House Democrats in the wake of Floyd’s death would make it easier for injured individual­s to claim damages in civil suits against police offices.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from United States