Bias questions raised after hearing
FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. — When Wyoming Sen. John Barrasso snapped at Deb Haaland during her confirmation hearing, many in Indian Country were incensed.
The exchange, coupled with descriptions of the Interior secretary nominee as “radical” — by other white, male Republicans — left some feeling Haaland is being treated differently because she is a Native American woman.
“If it was any other person, they would not be subjected to being held accountable for their ethnicity,” said Cheryl AndrewsMaltais, chairwoman of the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head Aquinnah in Massachusetts.
At Wednesday’s hearing, Barrasso wanted assurance that Haaland would follow the law when it comes to imperiled species. Before the congresswoman finished her response, Barrasso shouted, “I’m talking about the law!”
Barrasso, former chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee, later said his uncharacteristic reaction was a sign of frustration over Haaland dodging questions.
“My constituents deserve straight answers from the potential secretary about the law,” he said in a statement. “They got very few of those.”
Among Haaland supporters across the nation who tuned in virtually, it was infuriating.
“It was horrible. It was disrespectful,” said Rebecca Ortega of Santa Clara Pueblo in Haaland’s home state of New Mexico. “I just feel like if it would have been a white man or a white woman, he would never have yelled like that.”
The Interior Department has broad oversight of energy development, along with tribal affairs, and some Republican senators have labeled Haaland “radical” over her calls to reduce dependence on fossil fuels and address climate change. They said that could hurt rural America and major oil and gasproducing states. Louisiana Sen. John Kennedy after two days of hearings called Haaland a “neosocialist, left-of-Lenin whack job.”
AndrewsMaltais saw “radical” as a code for “you’re an Indian.”
But Republican Sen. Steve Daines of Montana said it’s not about race. Daines frequently uses the term to describe Democrats and their policies, including President Biden and former Montana Gov. Steve Bullock, whom Daines defeated in November.
“As much as I would love to see a Native American be on the president’s Cabinet, I have concerns about her record. … To say otherwise is outrageous and offensive,” he said.
Civil rights activists say Haaland’s treatment fits a pattern of minority nominees encountering more political resistance than white counterparts.
The confirmation of Neera Tanden, who would be the first Indian American to head the Office of Management and Budget, was thrown into doubt when it lost support from Democratic Sen. Joe Manchin of West Virginia. He cited her controversial tweets attacking members of both parties.
Despite Republican opposition, Haaland has enough Democratic support to become the first Native American to lead the Interior Department.